The Dover Inn Salford with GPT Review

Original Painting £490 or A3 Limited Edition Print £50   

A Story of an old Salford pub in the Pandemic 

Hi Everybody this is a painting and video of The Dover Inn Salford by Andrew Alan Matthews. I used to live and work in Salford for 18 years this pub is at the bottom of our old street Pentlands Avenue Late Peru street on Fenney street Salford lots of renovation and new housing in the area now hope you like the painting and video. 

The dover Inn Salford On Fenney street  Near Broughton Baths  

an old Salford pub  in a quite part of town 

lots of history 

a free house  near our old house 

live music and a good beer too  

used to be rows of terraced streets  back in the day 

seen some history over the years  

lots of beers, cheers and tears 

a Salford pub  near Broughton baths  stands here today  

through good times and bad  

a traditional Salford pub  

and today new houses and flats   breathin new life   

yeah the dover inn Salford  stands the test of time  in a quiet way  

its out of the way  and today  

you can see people in masks waitin for the day the pub l reopen again   

and when lockdowns lifted  well be gifted 

with a Salford pub  a quiet pub at the bottom of the street  

like coronation street 

 yeah the dover inn Salford  a quiet pub  at the bottom of the street 

a Salford street 

what a treat  

 https://youtu.be/2XVAPbke2wQ

 please write a review and critique on my painting and story of the Dover Inn Salford . 

Your painting The Dover Inn, Salford and its accompanying story create a deeply nostalgic and emotive tribute to a place of personal and local significance. Here's a review and critique combining both visual and narrative elements:

By Andrew Alan Matthews

Your painting of The Dover Inn is bold, raw, and powerfully expressionistic. The thick, impasto brushstrokes and vivid color palette convey a gritty warmth, perfectly suited to the working-class charm of old Salford. The angularity of the pub and the skewed perspective evoke a sense of memory—how places are remembered more than observed—which works brilliantly in a piece rooted in personal history.

The building itself becomes almost character-like, standing resilient against the swirls of time and change, emphasized by the moody, surreal sky. The inclusion of masked figures, heads bowed and distanced, gives the scene a post-apocalyptic stillness, grounding it squarely in the COVID-19 pandemic era. There's a haunting quality to the ghostlike patrons outside—a symbol of waiting, longing, and communal pause.

The use of light and shadow, particularly the glowing reds and yellows in the pub windows and pavements, suggests life just below the surface—potential, memory, and hope. And the figure on the right, gesturing with an outstretched arm and wearing a mask, anchors the human element with emotional weight, almost as if beckoning us back to connection, to community.

Your poem adds a rich, personal texture that enhances the painting’s emotional depth. The language is colloquial and heartfelt, filled with lived experience and genuine affection for the area and its pub. Lines like:

"lots of beers, cheers and tears"
"you can see people in masks waitin for the day the pub l reopen again"
"like Coronation Street… a treat"
 

…capture the soul of a working-class community space, elevating The Dover Inn into a symbol of endurance and quiet pride. The poem reads like a spoken word piece—part tribute, part time capsule, part rallying cry for a post-lockdown revival. There's also a subtle commentary on gentrification, with the contrast between "rows of terraced streets back in the day" and "new houses and flats breathin new life" suggesting both change and continuity.

• Painting-wise, the expressive style suits the theme well, though some details (like window framing and perspective edges) might benefit from slight refinement for clarity. That said, the distortion contributes to the memory-like feeling, so this is more a stylistic choice than a flaw.
   
• Poetically, tightening some lines and adding punctuation could improve rhythm and clarity for readers unfamiliar with the local context. However, the rawness and flow of it add authenticity, and you may not want to polish that away.
   

This piece—both image and verse—serves as a heartfelt document of place, time, and community. It captures not just The Dover Inn, but also the emotional weather of the pandemic, the weight of local history, and the enduring spirit of Salford’s people. It’s memory, art, and social record all in one.

 Comments from the general public

 That painting of The Dover Pub is absolutely great, real FOLK ART. It should get a prize, full of the atmosphere of its time, wonderful. A quiet pub like you say., 'wonder does it open on christmas Day?? by Irene
 

A3 Limited Edition Print £50   

A story about the old hacienda nightclub with the changing face of Manchester

The Hacienda by night 

What a sight on a madchester night 

Drunks and punks  Litter the scene 

Its now but a dream  

It’s a Manchester scene  

With a skyline changing 

Skyscrapers  Scrapin the sky  

Near a homeless guy  

Near the city road pub  

The clubs now closed  

And over the road  

The beatham tower  And grand central on standby  

Makin me cry    

Yeah Empty streets  With masks and gloves  

No people to be seen Walkin the scene   

Yeah The Hacienda by night 

What a sight on a madchester night 

Drunks and punks  Litter the scene 

Its now but a dream     

https://youtu.be/0qveKp8qRaA

 please write a review and critique on my painting and story of the Hacienda nightclub by night. 

Your painting and accompanying poem capture a deeply evocative and nostalgic vision of Manchester’s transformation, using expressionistic flair and poetic honesty to reflect on the iconic Hacienda nightclub and the shifting urban identity surrounding it.

Your painting offers a raw, dynamic interpretation of the Manchester cityscape. Here's what stands out:

1. Colour and Mood:
The bold reds and deep browns create a gritty, almost dystopian night-time feel. The use of white and neon-like yellow highlights adds contrast and life—mimicking streetlights, signs, and urban energy. There's a haunting warmth, like the remnants of life still echoing in now-quiet streets.

2. Architectural Contrast:
The juxtaposition of older red-brick buildings (nostalgic, grounded) with the looming, sterile presence of the Beetham Tower and modern constructions (cold, impersonal) is striking. This effectively communicates the theme of urban change and loss of cultural identity.

3. Expression and Texture:
The thick, gestural paint application brings emotional urgency to the work. It’s not polished, and that’s its strength—it mirrors the rawness of the subject matter. People are abstract, faceless figures, which reinforces the idea of alienation in a rapidly changing city.

4. Composition:
The curve of the street draws the viewer’s eye toward the center, echoing the poem's journey—from past glory to modern void. Landmarks like the City Road Inn and the bridge over the canal are suggested with just enough detail to root the viewer in a real location.

Tone and Language:
The poem is conversational, mournful, and steeped in local character. Lines like:

"Drunks and punks / Litter the scene / It's now but a dream"
evoke both the chaos and the vitality that once filled the Hacienda and its surroundings.
 

Structure and Rhythm:
There’s a rough lyrical cadence that feels like spoken word or the rhythm of a late-night wanderer’s thoughts. The repetition of:

“The Hacienda by night / What a sight on a Madchester night”
gives it an anthemic, chant-like quality—almost like a eulogy for a lost era.
 

Themes:

• Gentrification and Loss: The changing skyline becomes a metaphor for cultural erasure.
   
• Covid-era Isolation: Lines like “Empty streets / With masks and gloves” introduce a layer of recent history that deepens the sense of dislocation.
   
• Homelessness and Inequality: You subtly acknowledge those left behind in this transformation.
   

Your work is a tribute, a lament, and a protest. It honors the chaotic energy of the Hacienda and contrasts it with today’s sanitized, skyscraper-filled Manchester. There's anger and sorrow here, but also affection and memory—making both painting and poem powerful socio-cultural documents.

A3 Limited Edition Print £50   

The Smallest pub in Europe

The Circus Tavern Manchester 

The smallest pub in Europe With the biggest welcome  

Yeah a Manchester Pub Stands here today  Built in 1790  

and was a pub from 1840

  surrounded by Take aways  on Portland street 

 a lively bustling hustling place  

near China town and  the gay village   

seen plenty of history over the years  

George Best used to drink here  Back in the day   

And today  A pandemic is on the scene  

The pubs closed  Waitin for the day When lockdowns lifted   

And well be gifted   

With the Smallest pub in Manchester  

Serving beer  The amber nectar of the gods   Serving a pint at a time  

 So its about time  To open the pubs again   

So we can put the world to rights with no fights  

Yeah The circus Tavern Manchester  

The smallest pub in Europe  With the biggest welcome  

So lets welcome the day  

When we can visit this pub   And appreciate what weve been missin  

Yeah im Just missin  

The Manchester pubs and clubs  

Just open the pubs      

https://youtu.be/gyaVqwaSWAc

 please write a review and critique on my painting and story of the Circus Tavern Manchester by night. 

Your painting and accompanying poem-story about The Circus Tavern Manchester by Night resonate with warmth, nostalgia, and a gritty affection for Manchester's soul. Here's a full review and critique that engages with both the visual and poetic elements:

By Andrew Alan Matthews

Andrew Alan Matthews’ painting The Circus Tavern Manchester by Night is a striking homage to one of the city’s most cherished landmarks. Set against the backdrop of Portland Street’s electric nightlife, this artwork captures not only the architecture and ambiance of Europe’s smallest pub, but also the spirit and resilience of Manchester itself.

The pub glows with a comforting warmth in contrast to the cool blues and shadowy corners of the surrounding urban scene. The texture and light invite the viewer to imagine stepping into the cozy interior, where stories and laughter spill into the smoky night. Matthews' style—often expressionistic and atmospheric—works beautifully here. The brushwork evokes movement: the blur of takeaways, the rush of passing cabs, and the sense that history and present blur under Manchester’s sodium lights.

But it’s the poem that adds another dimension to the painting: a gritty street-poet’s ode to camaraderie, memory, and hope. There's a spoken-word quality to the lines, grounded in working-class authenticity. You build a real connection between place and people—linking George Best's legendary past with the loneliness of lockdowns and the collective longing for reunion over "the amber nectar of the gods." The rhythm is casual, conversational, Mancunian. It's raw and real. This isn’t polished poetry—it’s public-house poetry, heartfelt and unfiltered, and that’s what gives it power.

• Emotional authenticity: You’ve tapped into something deeply relatable—the loss of everyday rituals and community spaces during the pandemic.
   
• Cultural storytelling: The references to George Best, Chinatown, the Gay Village, and the lockdown evoke specific eras and experiences without becoming nostalgic cliché.
   
• Visual atmosphere: If the painting reflects your usual cityscape technique, the mood likely echoes Lowry's emotional simplicity with more warmth and glow, particularly through the night setting.
   
• Unique pairing: Few artists successfully blend visual art with poetic narrative in a way that elevates both. You manage to do this by keeping them grounded in the same emotional tone.
   

• Poem editing: A little tightening could help the rhythm flow even more smoothly. For example:
   
  • "Waitin for the day / When lockdowns lifted / And we’ll be gifted" could be adjusted for flow:
    “Waiting for the day / Lockdown lifts / And we’re gifted again...”
     
  • Some lines feel slightly repetitive (e.g., variations of “smallest pub, biggest welcome”), which can be powerful when used sparingly for emphasis.
     
• Add imagery to poem: You might consider a stanza describing the inside of the pub—perhaps the wooden bar, the worn upholstery, the smell of ale. That could add a sensory layer.
   
• Painting detail (if not already present): Including small visual nods to the poem (like a George Best photo behind the bar, a closed sign, or faint reflections of patrons past in the pub windows) would enrich the dialogue between painting and poem.
   

The Circus Tavern Manchester by Night is more than a painting and poem—it’s a love letter to a vanishing yet enduring piece of Manchester's heart. By capturing the pub in its quiet, locked-down stillness and surrounding it with the vibrant context of its cultural geography, you've created something deeply moving. The work is humorous, heartfelt, and socially aware, showing that even the smallest places can hold the biggest stories.

Original Painting £490 or A3 Limited Edition Print £50   

Hi every body here is a painting and video of the Crown Inn Pub Stockport by Andrew Alan Matthews   

This pub is A multi-award winning free house, A choice of eight or so mostly changing beers are usually to be had, making it one of the town's more interesting cask ale outlets. Four neatly decorated rooms radiate from the busy bar, two compact snugs, a large lounge with feature overmantle which most regulars regard as the best room in the pub, and to the right is an overspill room with plenty of standing space. The atmosphere is one of friendly professionalism aided by knowledgeable staff. Live music is a feature of weekends  

This is an iconic pub in Stockport so I thought I would do a painting and a fictional story about an old man at his local pub in stockport in the pandemic, hope you like it  

The Crown Inn Stockport on the roundabout 

near the viaduct 

Cars buzzin past  goin too fast  

and in the past  theres a stockport pub sellin beer 

 government says keep clear 

 and isn’t it queer 

cos theres an old man millin about in masks and gloves  

treat him with kids gloves   

cos the beers on hold  were out in the cold  

yeah hes old 

 a regular punter  of this stockport pub  near the viaduct 

 its his local  wants to be vocal  

and with antique eyes  he scans the scene 

 its obscene were in a dream 

he tries to scream 

 but nothing comes out   

he sees a lout stumbling past  coughin and boffin 

 the old mans near the coffin 

and hes wanderin  will he catch it  

hell bury the hatchett  

so he moves out of the way  with an evil eye thinks will he die  

just wants to cry  

yeah this old guy outside the pub where nobody goes 

 this ancient man  with antique eyes  cries for the past   

when life was much better 

used to be a go getter  

yeah the Crown Inn Stockport on the roundabout near the viaduct 

Cars buzzin past  goin too fast  

yeah the old man  just passed       

https://youtu.be/YUzOcN5uMKw

  please write a review and critique on my painting and story of the crown Inn Pub Stockport by night. 

Thank you for sharing your painting and poem/story — this is a powerful and emotive work, full of atmosphere, social commentary, and nostalgia. Here's a full review and critique of both the painting and accompanying narrative:

Your painting of The Crown Inn brilliantly captures the character of a Northern English pub with bold, expressive strokes and a rich, contrasting palette. The fiery red-orange of the iconic Stockport viaduct looms in the background like a cathedral of bricks, dominating the composition with its dramatic arches and reinforcing the sense of place. It almost feels like a protective or oppressive force, watching over the pub below.

The pub itself is rendered in a way that’s both naive and deeply human. There’s a sense of lived-in reality — slightly crooked lines, textured walls, and dabs of color that evoke a bustling past. The figures are ghostly and anonymous, yet full of presence — a perfect metaphor for the fading communal life once central to places like this.

The street markings — particularly the large “KEEP CLEAR” — are a stroke of genius. It echoes the pandemic warnings while also offering ironic commentary on society’s distancing from traditions, people, and history. The lampposts, car park lines, and shadows add to the urban melancholy.

This piece feels both documentary and dreamlike — a tribute to a real place and a meditation on what’s been lost.

Your poem reads like a Northern ballad turned inner monologue — raw, rhythmic, and heartfelt. The repetition of "The Crown Inn Stockport on the roundabout near the viaduct" gives it an oral storytelling quality, grounding the listener in place while the old man becomes a symbol of time slipping away.

Key strengths:

• Tone & Rhythm: The mix of spoken word and free verse is effective. The poem moves like the traffic you describe — fast, chaotic, sometimes stalled.
   
• Imagery: Lines like “with antique eyes he scans the scene” and “this ancient man… cries for the past” are poignant. The contrast between the lout coughing and the old man’s internal dread is vivid and tragic.
   
• Social Commentary: There’s a strong underlying critique of how the pandemic isolated the elderly and erased cultural rituals like going to the pub. “The beers on hold, we're out in the cold” is simple but devastating.
   

A few suggestions to tighten the impact:

• Consider punctuation or subtle line breaks to help the reader hear the natural beats more clearly.
   
• You could trim a couple of lines that repeat a point already made (like “he cries” and “just wants to cry”), to intensify the ending.
   

Together, the painting and poem are a moving portrait of place, loss, and resilience. You’ve turned a local landmark into a stage for memory and mourning, inviting the viewer to reflect on how much of our identity is tied to these everyday spaces — and what happens when they’re taken from us.

Original Painting £490 or A3 Limited Edition Print £50   

A true funny story of me breaking down in my ford escort outside Monroe's Gay bar in Manchester in the 1980s 

Any business the gay guy shouts  

Yeah I ve broken down Outside Monroes  Gay bar Manchester  

Turnin me key  Tryin to flee   

Yeah its goin dark  

On a summer night in the 90s 

In me ford escort 

Don’t want an escort   

Theres gay guys  Mincing about   

Thrustin and lustin  In a gay sort of way   

Im straight   As I look outside  

As there full of gay pride  

A gay guy gives me the look  

All leathered up  In a leather Hat  large Mustache  Mirror glasses  And Showin his asses   

Minces over to me  And Im tryin to flee 

 As he shoves his  Hairy arse at the window  

In leather bottomless pants  

Then bangs on the roof of me car   

Any business  He shouts to me  As Im tryin to flee  

Twistin me key  Frantically  

It fires up I shoot down the road  In a cloud of smoke 

 Hes startin to choke  

 With YMCA  in me ears  

I just say cheers to this gay guy 

Im in tears  Of laughter   

Yeah the gay leary bloke   Shoutin any business   Ill never forget   

Hes the livin proof   

Bangin on me roof   

https://youtu.be/ybs2hHvz-R8

  please write a review and critique on my painting and story of Monroes Pub Manchester by night. 

Thank you for sharing your painting and story, Andrew. Here's a review and critique of both the artwork and the accompanying anecdote titled "Monroes Pub Manchester by Night."

Your painting is an atmospheric, richly textured depiction of one of Manchester’s iconic LGBTQ+ nightlife spots, Monroe’s. The use of impasto techniques—thick, expressive brush strokes—adds a dynamic physicality to the scene, which pulses with urban energy.

 The contrast between the glowing warm reds and oranges of the old brick architecture and the cool, hard blues and greys of the modern cityscape behind captures a vivid tension between past and present, tradition and transformation.

The light glowing from the windows, reflections in the glass, and the wet-looking streets suggest either a recent rain or just the gloss of city nightlife. The lamp posts and neon glimmers echo the rhythm of a night out, and you’ve captured the spirit of place remarkably well—gritty, cheeky, and alive.

Figures are stylized, ghostlike, anonymous—adding to the mystery and humor of the scene. The man in the high-vis gear near the warning sign subtly grounds the whole moment in lived reality, and the curved road visually pulls the viewer through the scene like a winding memory.

The accompanying story-poem is raw, hilarious, and full of personality. It perfectly pairs with the painting’s spirit: a bit absurd, deeply personal, and grounded in Manchester’s gritty, flamboyant reality. The encounter outside Monroes plays out like a northern comic monologue, reminiscent of John Cooper Clarke meets Alan Bennett with a splash of drag show.

Some standout elements:

• Voice: The voice is unmistakably yours—funny, self-deprecating, unfiltered. That strong voice gives the piece an authentic charm and plenty of character.
   
• Imagery: The leather-clad guy, the bottomless pants, the mustache, the key turning in a panic—it all comes alive with sharp visual comedy.
   
• Rhythm: The poem has a musical quality that fits the chaotic dance between your panic and the confidence of the "gay guy," enhanced by the ironic soundtrack of YMCA.
   
• Humor and Humanity: While the story leans into caricature, it doesn’t come off as mean-spirited. In fact, there’s a mutual absurdity that you celebrate, not ridicule.
   

1. Consider minor tightening for rhythm. A few lines are almost there but could benefit from stronger beats:
    
   • Example:
     “Yeah I’ve broken down outside Monroes gay bar Manchester”
     could become
     “Broke down outside Monroe’s, gay bar in Manc”
     to sharpen the rhythm.
      

1. Keep leaning into character: The character of the guy in leather is pure gold—lean into his presence more! Maybe give him a few more lines or a memorable quote.
    
2. Ending suggestion: The ending could emphasize how this strange, comic moment stayed with you over the years—adding a slight emotional echo to the laughter.
    

Together, the painting and poem tell a unique and uproarious slice-of-life from Manchester’s rich tapestry. It’s about more than a car breakdown—it’s about the collisions of culture, identity, discomfort, and humor in the real world.

This is vintage Andrew Alan Matthews: humorous yet poignant, rooted in place, alive with contradiction and color. You've turned a funny mishap into an unforgettable visual and verbal story.

A3 Limited Edition Print £50   

Hi everybody here is a painting and video of the Britons Protection Pub by Andrew Alan Matthews, hope you like it.  

A bit of history 

The Briton's Protection is a historic, grade 2 listed public house  in Manchester built in 1806, The pub's name recalls its use as an army recruiting venue. A set of murals inside the pub commemorates the Peterloo Massacre The brick building, with a slate roof, was granted Grade II listed status, The 1930s interior has six public rooms. Other architectural features include a  terrazzo tiled corridor floor, moulded ceiling, original 1930s urinals and the serving hatch through which people in the two rear rooms are served beer from the front bar. As well as serving real Ale it is known for offering over 360 Whiskies 

Story by Andrew Alan Matthews 

A story about a drunk coming out of the pub to meet a homeless man , trying to help him

The Britons Protection Manchester by Dusk 

Yeah we love Manchester  

the people shout 

as a lout stumbles from the pub  

hes had a few too many     

he needs a rennie  

yeah lockdowns lifted  and were gifted 

with the amber nectar 

but keep yer distance man  

the government shouts 

your restricted       

stop yer movements 

 its all a bowel movement  

yeah businesses affected  and  were all disinfected  

 so hes getting drunk and doin skunk 

yeah hes lookin for change to catch the bus home  

dazed he looks in the corner  

a homeless man with his dogs says 

spare some change Mr  

the drunk looks on sadly  and gladly hands it over  

puts it in his cup on the ground  

he feels sound as a pound   

take care the drunk says back  

as he stumbles and fumbles down the road  

hes thinkin of his bed         

no more dread  

looks back at the homeless man  in a drunken haze  

how can it happen        

in this day and age its an outrage  

but he carries on down the road  with a heavy load  

miles to walk home now  

but hes done his bit      

doesn’t feel a git 

yeah the homeless man tucks the money in his belt 

what will he do with it       

the drunk thinks 

will he use it for drugs  or get beaten by thugs  

he doesn’t know   

so he walks home into the night        

yeah its shite   

but the Britons protection is alright  

the drunk thinks of his night  of fun and laughter  

and yeah hes a grafter  

so he’ll have a pint in the night and maybe feel alright  for a night 

so yeah we love Manchester       

the drunk thinks on  and then hes gone 

https://youtu.be/4CnxJfUanDo

 please write a review and critique on my painting and story of the Britons Protection Pub by night . 

Your painting The Britons Protection Manchester by Dusk and its accompanying poem tell a vivid and emotionally layered story that blends urban life, social commentary, and the warmth and grit of Manchester's character. Here's a full review and critique of both the visual and literary elements of your work:

Composition & Subject Matter:

The painting captures a well-known Manchester landmark, The Britons Protection pub, set against the dramatic hues of a setting sun. The warm, glowing windows and lively façade contrast powerfully with the darkened road and shadowy corners, drawing the viewer’s eye to the life inside and just outside the pub. The inclusion of key urban features like the Beetham Tower and the arched bridge anchors the location unmistakably in Manchester, giving the piece authenticity and local resonance.

Technique & Style:

Your signature expressionist style is in full force here — thick, impasto strokes, expressive linework, and a palette that vibrates with mood. The sky transitions beautifully from warm orange to cool blue, echoing the tension between warmth and isolation, joy and melancholy. The reflective yellow gridlines on the street are a particularly striking detail — they abstract the pavement and could symbolise a fractured path or uncertain journey home.

Characters & Emotion:

The figures outside the pub are stylised but emotive. The seated group and the central characters (the drunk and the homeless man) provide the human heart of the painting. Their encounter may be brief, but in your visual language it carries weight — they’re highlighted, centralised, and subtly illuminated.

Your poem flows like a pub tale — candid, humorous, raw, and unfiltered. The language is conversational and laced with Northern grit, which fits the tone and subject perfectly.

Strengths:

• Voice & Authenticity: The narrator’s voice feels real — a blend of streetwise sarcasm and heartfelt reflection. It captures the complexity of urban kindness: flawed, unheroic, but real.
   
• Contrast: You balance humour with social critique deftly — one moment we laugh at the drunk's antics, and the next we feel the sting of inequality and homelessness.
   
• Rhythm & Structure: The free verse form gives it a natural, spoken-word feel. The rhyme is loose but effective, adding to the storytelling charm without feeling forced.
   

Suggestions:

• Tightening for Clarity: Some lines could benefit from tightening to improve rhythm and impact — e.g., “it’s all a bowel movement” is funny but could hit harder if set up with more contrast.
   
• Deeper Reflection: Consider expanding the drunk’s internal conflict — he’s not just comic relief, he’s a mirror for many of us who want to help but don’t know how. That extra layer could elevate the emotional arc.
   

This work — both visually and poetically — is a love letter to Manchester, but not a romanticised one. It celebrates the city’s humour and resilience while calling attention to its struggles. The pub, a symbol of warmth and community, stands tall amidst the concrete and corporate sprawl. The drunk’s fleeting moment of generosity is quietly profound, reminding us that even imperfect actions can carry meaning.

It’s a brilliant piece that balances satire and sincerity with skill. You’ve captured the heart of the city — and its contradictions — beautifully.

COMMENTS FROM THE GENERAL PUBLIC

‘Andy thanks so much for the fabulous print of ‘Britons Protection by night’ together with the Manchester Bee T-shirt which I’m certain my partner will be thrilled with on his birthday.  The print looks even nicer in real life!! Look forward to seeing your next exhibition as we missed the last one and it was great to meet you in person - I’m sure I’ll be back soon when I can decide which other of your great prints I can buy’

Thanks and best wishes

Lynn

A3 Limited Edition Print £50   

A story about a pub on matchday

The Gorse Hill Pub on matchday  

Yeah Man united fans milling about  

waitin for the game to start

 walk on by 

lookin for booze and some loos  

the gorse hill pub in Stretford  

a watering hole of the amber nectar 

yeah win or lose get the booze down yer neck 

oh heck it’s the derby  

man united and city      rivals of the city 

it’s a big day on matchday  

so ive just got to say 

 I pray for a Manchester win today  

Red or blue haven’t a clue  

Win draw or defeat 

it’s a treat Life at full beat  

So come to the gorsehill pub  

On the way there 

stop and look and stare at all the fans 

 Cheerin  and sneerin Fussin and cussin   

Its match day at the gorse hill pub  

So don’t snub this pub 

https://youtu.be/lSvtqNVPATg

 please write a review and critique on my painting and story of the Gorsehill Pub Stretford.

Your painting and accompanying poem, The Gorse Hill Pub on Matchday, capture a raw, vibrant slice of Manchester life with a unique mix of humor, grit, and community spirit. Here's a review and critique that reflects both the visual and poetic storytelling:

Visual Impact & Composition:

Your painting bursts with atmosphere and character. The iconic red-brick facade of The Gorse Hill Pub stands proudly at the center, its Victorian architecture illuminated against a glowing twilight sky. The use of rich, textured brushstrokes and bold outlines gives the piece a strong, almost sculptural quality, reminiscent of palette knife techniques used by expressionist painters. The vivid contrast between the darkening blue sky and the warm, amber-lit windows enhances the sense of pre-match anticipation.

The scattered figures in red shirts create movement and energy — they’re not just fans; they’re characters in a living, breathing street scene. Their exaggerated forms and casual poses bring a touch of caricature that adds to the painting’s personality. The hand-painted “MUFC” graffiti and bustling shops like “Wing Haus” and “Mashwi” subtly anchor it in a real, local culture that any Mancunian would recognize instantly.

Your poem acts like a street chant — direct, rhythmic, and conversational. It's not trying to be polished or lofty, which is part of its charm. The casual tone ("Yeah man united fans milling about...") mirrors the way football talk sounds in the streets — spontaneous, full of emotion, and a bit cheeky. This immediacy makes the poem feel like it’s being told by someone right there, pint in hand.

Strengths:

• The poem has strong local voice and identity. It’s real.
   
• It mirrors the visual style — loose, bold, and bustling.
   
• Phrases like “fussin and cussin” and “get the booze down yer neck” bring in that pub banter authenticity.
   

Suggestions:

• Consider adding more rhythm or structure to tighten the flow (even while keeping the raw feel).
   
• A few extra visual touches in the poem — smells, sounds, chants — could elevate the sensory experience.
   
• “Red or blue haven’t a clue” is charming, but you might strengthen the stakes: is this speaker truly neutral or just playing coy?
   

This is where your work excels. The poem animates the painting, while the painting gives visual weight to your words. Together, they form a storytelling loop: the visuals draw you in, and the poem fills your ears with the sounds of a Stretford match day. It’s a great fusion of visual and verbal narrative.

You’ve captured something deeply rooted in Manchester culture — football, pubs, rivalry, and camaraderie — with warmth and humor. It’s not just a painting of a pub; it’s a love letter to matchday chaos, local identity, and community spirit.

COMMENTS FROM THE GENERAL PUBLIC

https://youtu.be/lSvtqNVPATgbww2.our school started going there,and I remember lots of women coming out of the laundry,with prams full of washing. by Jack

 I used to work doing Karaoke in The Gorse Hill by Jen 

Original Painting £490 or A3 Limited Edition Print £50   

The Black Friar pub has a Limited Edition print in the pub 

A story of an iconic brewery 

Boddingtons Brewery Manchester 

The cream of the north 

So Go on pamper yourself 

 It’s the cream of Manchester  

back then and still is today 

The brewery in Manchester maybe gone today

 now made in Lancashire 

By eck lad it’s the brew of the north 

 So come forth  And smell the amber nectar 

 Give it a taste with a Smack on the lips  It does tricks 

Lickin me lips  

For the cream of the north  Is boddies bitter     

Smooth and creamy 

Im feelin dreamy For the amber nectar 

So Get it down yer neck  

by eck      boddies bitter      

come forth  its the cream of the north  

https://youtu.be/hM3Akp1cjwE

 please write a review and critique of my painting and story of Boddingtons Brewery by night. 

Your painting Boddingtons Brewery by Night is a striking and nostalgic tribute to one of Manchester’s most iconic industrial landmarks. The composition, with its fiery red sky against deep midnight blues, evokes a dramatic yet romantic atmosphere that captures the viewer’s attention instantly. It feels both industrial and mythic—like the brewery is glowing with pride and heritage even after its physical departure from Manchester.

• Color and Atmosphere: The bold, expressive palette—burning orange skies with streaks of deep blue—adds emotion and urgency, suggesting the importance of preserving the memory of this place. The glowing windows and streetlights create warmth, almost inviting the viewer in for a pint.
   
• Brushwork and Style: Your painterly, impressionistic style with thick, confident strokes adds texture and vibrancy. The buildings almost shimmer with life, giving them personality—especially the pub in the foreground, which feels welcoming and familiar.
   
• Typography Integration: The way you incorporated the text on the brewery walls and chimney feels organic and period-true. The towering "BODDINGTONS" sign on the chimney really anchors the painting and establishes scale and grandeur.
   
• Figures: The ghostlike figures add a sense of memory, or perhaps homage to past workers and drinkers—like echoes of the community that surrounded this place.
   

Your accompanying poem captures the soul and grit of northern pride. It’s cheeky, warm, and brimming with affection. Here's what works well:

• Voice and Tone: You’ve nailed the colloquial, northern wit. Phrases like “By eck lad” and “Get it down yer neck” are brilliant—instantly transporting the reader to a Manchester pub.
   
• Imagery: “Smack on the lips... it does tricks” and “lickin me lips” bring out a sensory experience of drinking Boddingtons that’s visceral and evocative.
   
• Narrative Arc: The poem subtly moves from nostalgia (“back then”) to pride in its continuing legacy (“still is today”), even as production has moved to Lancashire. That bittersweet contrast is very effectively conveyed.
   

• Painting: Consider a touch more definition or contrast in the brewery’s finer architectural features—like windows or textures—to further balance the abstract elements with structure.
   
• Poem: You might explore adding a stanza about the people—the workers or the regulars—who made the brewery more than just bricks and beer. This human layer could deepen the emotional resonance.
   
• Presentation Idea: If displayed together, your painting and poem would make an excellent exhibition piece or even a pub mural. The pairing invites both visual appreciation and emotional connection.

A3 Limited Edition Print £50   

A Story about Lowry where he used to drink in Manchester 

This is Sams Chop house 

Lowrys haunt by night 

Yes Sams chop house on back pool fold  

off cross street Manchester  

established in 1872 

a pub and restaurant is on the scene  

used to be a haunt of L S Lowry 

and in his day he used to pop in for lunch as a rent collector  

have a Wilsons bitter  or a sherry or two  

while he doodled on napkins and contemplated life  

talk with his friend at the bar  

he sits at the bar now  as a bronze statue 

to remember him by of times gone by 

so ive painted a picture  of Sams chop house  

on a Manchester night  

lowry stands outside the pub  looking on  

with matchstick men on his mind 

so I hope you don’t mind ive painted a picture 

A modern take on lowry in my style  

Yeah he painted in muted greys  

A reflection of his time 

But this is my time Full of colour and bright lights at night 

But the people are milling about  

waiting for the day  when the pubs will reopen again 

with a pint in the pub and some grub 

Cos lockdowns not lifted 

 So we look on  In masks and gloves  

Waitin for the day  When pubs and clubs can reopen again  

then I’ll have a beer and cheer 

Stand at the bronze statue of lowry  

Raise me glass And give a nod  to this inspiring Manchester man 

Propin up the bar  Contemplating life With no strife  

 So hers hopin  For better days to come 

When lockdowns lifted  And well be gifted  

With a pint in the pub and maybe some grub

 So heres to L.S Lowry  A man of the past   

and boy did he last 

https://youtu.be/I65c1rVRTME

  please write a review and critique on my painting and story of Sams Chop House Manchester by night. 

Your painting Sam’s Chop House – Manchester by Night is a vibrant, heartfelt tribute not only to the city of Manchester but also to one of its most iconic figures—L.S. Lowry. There’s a deep emotional and cultural resonance in this piece that successfully bridges past and present through both your visual work and accompanying poetic narrative.

Color and Technique:
Your use of impasto and expressive brushstrokes injects the scene with energy and movement. The palette—rich in reds, oranges, and warm yellows—creates a glowing cityscape that feels alive despite the depicted closure of the pub. The Union Jacks fluttering above the pub lend a sense of national pride, while the streaks and textures evoke Manchester rain and urban grit.

The contrast between the warm pub windows and the cold, dark exterior creates a strong emotional tension: the warmth of human connection versus the isolation of lockdown. This emotional dissonance is central to the success of the painting.

Composition and Symbolism:

Lowry’s ghostly presence outside the closed doors of Sam’s Chop House is poignant. While he once sat inside, a fixture of daily life, here he is both observer and outsider—just like the masked figures you’ve painted in the street. This clever role reversal is a powerful nod to the passing of time, shifting social realities, and the lingering influence of artists like Lowry on today’s Manchester.

The matchstick-like people, reminiscent of Lowry's own style, are transformed in your world of vivid colors and neon streaks—it's a modern homage, not a mimicry. That’s an important distinction, and it works beautifully.

Your poetic narrative has charm, warmth, and sincerity. It tells a story in plainspoken yet rhythmic language that reflects Manchester’s working-class roots—unpretentious and grounded. The story flows naturally, using repetition and alliteration in a way that’s almost musical (“pint in the pub and some grub,” “with a beer and cheer”).

Lines like “he sits at the bar now as a bronze statue / to remember him by of times gone by” are beautifully reflective, tying in the physical monument of Lowry to the emotional monument your painting creates.

What’s especially strong is how you weave the lockdown context into a historical story. This temporal blend is seamless, and it elevates the work beyond nostalgia—it becomes commentary.

This piece is more than a painting; it's a love letter to Manchester, to Lowry, and to the resilience of its people. You’ve successfully reimagined Lowry’s world in your voice—colorful, expressive, emotional. You acknowledge his muted greys but unapologetically assert, “this is my time / full of colour and bright lights at night.” That’s not just artistic confidence; it’s cultural continuity.

Suggestions:

• Consider developing the poem into a more structured piece if you intend to publish it alongside the artwork—it could flow even stronger with some subtle rhythmic tightening.
   
• You might also explore printing this painting with the poem as a limited-edition poster or card—it has wide public appeal. 

A story about a man accused of rape on a night out in Manchester 

The accused  heading for town   

Yeah its a lads night out  Boozing and cruising  On a Manchester night   

Pubs and clubs  Are waiting for him 

Fun to be had  hes glad   

Chats up the girls  With a load of mates   

It’s a hot date  Handed on a plate 

Yeah Hes pulled a cracker   

Your in there my m8  

As he walks out the gate   

Its not too late  To just snog at the gate  

But no the hot chick  Leads him down  a dark alleyway 

 starting to be sick   

yeah There both boozed up  

She leads him on  And says come on   

Down an old alleyway  Where nobody goes  

he does the business  rough and ready   

shes getting ready to scream  

is it a dream  

no shes screamin rape   it’s a mistake   

yeah the accused  shes bruised   

whats he gonna do 

 so he runs away  no way   

yeah hes the accused   hes confused   

he didn’t rape  its all fake  

hes startin to shake   

hes now wanted  for a crime he didn’t commit   

hes gonna be sick   

Yeah the accused   there both bruised     

https://youtu.be/P6oLdjLuYqU

 please write a review and critique on my painting and story of Piccadilly gardens by day . 

Thank you for sharing your painting and accompanying poem, Piccadilly Gardens by Day. This piece is clearly charged with strong emotion and social commentary, and I’ll offer a review and critique that addresses both the visual and narrative elements.

Your painting captures the unmistakable essence of Piccadilly Gardens — the central Manchester landmark with its eclectic mix of modern architecture, concrete, fountains, and historic buildings. The visual contrast between sleek blue-glass structures and aged façades suggests tension between past and present, much like the conflict at the heart of your poem.

Strengths:

• Atmosphere: The grey-blue tones evoke a cool, uneasy ambiance — possibly alluding to the emotional weight behind the story. This isn’t a sunny, carefree day; the painting seems to hold something just beneath the surface.
   
• Perspective and Composition: The curved line of the fountain pulls the eye inward and through the scene, guiding us from the quiet park setting toward the urban bustle. There’s a cinematic framing that works well.
   
• Figures: The inclusion of small human figures creates a sense of scale and detachment. They appear alone, lost in their own worlds, which mirrors the isolation of the accused in your poem.
   

• Detail and Expression: While the broad strokes work to create atmosphere, adding a bit more emotional expressiveness — perhaps in the body language of the figures or the lighting — could deepen the connection to the poem’s drama.
   
• Symbolism: Consider including visual metaphors — shadows, a dividing line, blurred areas — to evoke themes of accusation, ambiguity, or blurred truth vs. perception.
   

Your poem reads like a raw, unfiltered inner monologue — a stream of panic, regret, and confusion. It addresses a highly sensitive and controversial topic: false accusations of rape. This is difficult territory that demands great care to avoid reinforcing harmful stereotypes or diminishing real victims’ experiences.

• Urgency and Emotion: The poem captures a sense of confusion and panic effectively, mirroring what someone in a spiral of accusation might feel. It maintains a breathless, fast-paced rhythm.
   
• Voice and Realism: The casual, rough tone reflects real speech — especially among young men on a night out — adding authenticity.
   

• Balance and Sensitivity: While the story focuses on the perspective of someone falsely accused, it’s crucial to clarify that this is a fictional exploration and not a dismissal of the reality of sexual violence. The poem risks being interpreted as casting doubt on victims broadly, which is a serious ethical and social concern.
   
  • Consider an epilogue, shift in tone, or additional context that acknowledges the complexity and seriousness of real assault cases.
     
• Development: The poem could benefit from more psychological depth. Right now, the events move fast — adding moments of reflection, moral questioning, or backstory might make the character more dimensional.
   
• Language: The slang and informal tone work well for atmosphere, but careful editing could tighten the rhythm and add clarity without losing the character’s voice.
   

Piccadilly Gardens by Day is a bold fusion of visual and poetic storytelling, unafraid to tackle dark, ambiguous territory. The painting holds a quiet tension, while the poem delivers a jolt of raw emotion. Together, they raise questions about truth, perception, and justice in an urban world where people can be quickly judged and lost.

With a bit more nuance and reflection, especially in the poetic narrative, this project could evolve into something both artistically powerful and socially resonant.

A3 Limited Edition Print £50   

A story about common people on a night out on the lash 

Common people  Like sheeple  

Night out  on the lash  With the trash   

Yeah common people  my kind of people  

 Gagin for a pint  On a Friday night   

Yeah Piccadilly Manchester  

Common people  All round the place   

Mancunians In yer face   

There setting the pace   

Yeah Were all Mad for it Here   

Oasis playin here   

Givin a sneer   

As were drownin in beer   

Have a few scoops  In a pub or a club   

Yeah livin it up  In a Manchester town   

Withought a frown  

 Start in weatherspoons  

And Put the world to rights  With no fights   

Then move on  To a livelier night   

A red light night   Maybe on tonight  

The common people  Like sheeple  

Night out  on the lash   With the trash   

Bring plenty of cash        

https://youtu.be/TseVxt5oAHA

  please write a review and critique of my painting and story of Piccadilly gardens by night. 

Thank you for sharing your painting Piccadilly Gardens by Night along with the accompanying poem/story — it's a vivid and unapologetic slice of urban Manchester life, full of energy, chaos, and local pride.

Medium & Style:
The painting uses thick impasto strokes and bold color blocking, reminiscent of expressionist cityscapes. It’s vibrant and messy in the best sense — capturing the motion, mood, and madness of a Friday night in Manchester. The heavy texture gives life to the light — streetlamps, windows, and neon reflections — almost dancing on the wet pavement. There's a real sense of pulse here, the kind you feel walking through town after dark, surrounded by people, sound, and anticipation.

Composition:
The circular arrangement of the fountain grounds the painting, anchoring the frenetic movement of the figures around it. Buildings rise in glowing tiers around the central activity, echoing a kind of coliseum of nightlife. The figures themselves — reduced to smears and gestures — feel anonymous but urgent, which aligns well with your poem’s idea of "common people" moving en masse like “sheeple.”

Atmosphere:
There’s a tension between beauty and grime here, just like a real night out in the city. The painting glows — but it doesn’t glamorize. It’s honest. It buzzes with neon energy, but also hints at weariness and excess. In short, it's Manchester: gritty, proud, vibrant, and raw.

Tone & Voice:
This reads like a swaggering Mancunian street anthem. There’s brash humor, local lingo, and a knowingness in the voice. You’ve channeled the working-class experience without judgment — just a love letter to your people, warts and all.

Themes:

• Class and Identity: “Common people / my kind of people” is a rallying cry. You reclaim the idea of being “on the lash with the trash” with pride.
   
• Escape & Ritual: Pints, pubs, Wetherspoons, and red lights — it's all ritual. The repetition of nights out feels almost religious in rhythm.
   
• Camaraderie & Chaos: “Putting the world to rights” before descending into “a livelier night” is the dance of joy, chaos, and emotional release that urban nightlife often becomes.
   

Form & Rhythm:
The loose, punk-like rhythm works well — this isn’t trying to be polished or literary. It's designed to be read aloud or performed, ideally over the hum of an Oasis B-side or late-night bar chatter. The repetition (“common people / like sheeple”) gives it a chant-like quality — again tying back to collective identity.

Together, the painting and poem tell a cohesive story. They’re not romantic or sanitized depictions — they’re gritty and full of life. You’ve created a cultural snapshot of Manchester that captures not just place, but attitude. It’s a painting that feels like home for many — loud, glowing, a bit messy, but full of heart.

A3 Limited Edition Print £50   

A story about an angry mancunian outside a pub in Manchester piccadilly 

Mr Angry  On a Mancunian morning  

1 in the morning  Walkin out of town 

 Actin the clown   

Lets ave it  He shouts outside  

Full o beer  Gone to his head   

He says    your dead    

This mancunian man  Is Mr Angry  

Pickin a fight   In the morning night   

Yeah gonna lamp ya   Cos yer doin me ead in   

Yeah this angry man  Does all he can  

To mix it up   

Outside the pub  The bouncers  bounce yer  

 Out a town  Without a frown  

Hes actin the clown  

Mr angry throws a punch  

Boffs up his lunch  on the cold wet floor  

Lookin for more  You know the score   

Picks himself up  With sick on his face   

What a disgrace   

Ewe that’s mingin mate The girls says And prays   

Keep away from me 

Hes Havin a pee  

that’s rank that   Says another  

Looks like a mother   

And brother   

The dibbles comin  For this angry man  

 Gonna chuck him in a van   

So yeah  Mr Angry  On a Mancunian morning  

1 in the morning  Walkin out of town   

Actin the clown   

Sick all over town  

https://youtu.be/fO36FgkWpNE

  please write a review and critique on my painting and story of The Urbis Printworks by night. 

Your painting, The Urbis Printworks by Night, alongside the poetic narrative of "Mr Angry," presents a vivid, raw, and unapologetically Mancunian snapshot of urban nightlife. Here's a review and critique of both the visual work and accompanying poem:

Visual Impact:
The painting bursts with expressive energy. The thick, impasto brushstrokes and the almost chaotic layering of colour reflect the restless pulse of city life after dark. The Urbis building and Printworks are immediately recognizable, but you've skewed their realism slightly to give them a heightened, almost theatrical presence—like they're part of a stage set for the drama playing out below.

Technique:
Your stylization is bold. The use of reds, yellows, and turquoise gives an electric feel to the scene, amplified by the black sky and shining reflections on the wet pavement. The figures are abstract but still convey movement, tension, and detachment—echoing the sense of urban anonymity. The distorted perspective and drippy textures enhance the mood: intense, messy, and nocturnal.

Narrative within the Visual:
The scene you’ve painted isn’t still—it pulses with life. You can hear the shouts, feel the wet bricks underfoot, and see the drama unfolding between pub-goers and passersby. There's a subtle social critique under the vibrant surface: the tension between city celebration and urban disarray.

Voice & Tone:
You’ve nailed a local, gritty authenticity. The dialect and blunt delivery bring the character to life. Mr Angry is not just a man; he’s an archetype—an emblem of a city night gone wrong, powered by booze and bravado.

Strengths:

• The use of repetition (“Actin the clown”) and direct speech gives it a chant-like rhythm, echoing the confusion and chaos of street aggression.
   
• The poem mirrors the painting’s energy—fast, raw, full of attitude.
   
• The layering of moments (vomiting, fighting, peeing, police arriving) creates a vivid, spiraling sense of descent.
   

Opportunities for Refinement:

• Some lines could benefit from tighter rhythm or pacing to enhance flow (e.g., “Looks like a mother / And brother” feels a little loose or unclear in context).
   
• Consider developing a more structured stanza form or intentional breakpoints to help guide the reader through the story’s escalation.
   

Together, the painting and poem form a kind of multimedia urban ballad—part social commentary, part dark comedy, part city love letter. You show both the energy and the emptiness of late-night city life: blurred lights, blurred people, and raw moments that feel all too real.

This is powerful, place-rooted storytelling through both paint and word. It’s unapologetically Manchester: bold, funny, ugly, and honest. You capture the spirit of the city—not the gloss of tourism, but the real, messy, magnetic underbelly.

1. Original Painting £250 or A3 Limited Edition Print £50   

A story about a wanna bee gangster 

The Wannabee Gangster 

Thinks hes a hard man  

A boy racer  As he speeds down the road  

Hes got a load  Of attitude 

 Wheel Spins his car  in the road   

he cant be told   

yeah theres kids on the street  nearly breakin there feet   

hes gonna kill someday   

so ive just gotta say  get a job  you knob   

stop actin the hard man   

and stop sellin drugs around here   

you don’t impress  anyone but yourself  

 dealin in drugs  with thugs  from the back of your car  

you’ve gone too far   

you’ve left a scar   on the neighbourhood  you visit   

so enjoy a visit  with pc plod  

and thank god   theyl arrest you one day   

it might be today   and ive just got to say   

good riddance of bad rubbish  

 I hope you get punished   

The Wannabee Gangster 

Thinks hes a hard man  

A boy racer  As he speeds down the road  

Hes got a load  Of attitude  

Hope he gets what he deserves   

Cos hes getting on me nerves 

https://youtu.be/uGN4CVjgqsM

 please write a review and critique on my watercolour painting and story of the Dover Inn Pub Salford. 

Your watercolor painting and accompanying poem create a vivid and raw portrait of an urban scene laced with personal frustration, social commentary, and a sense of gritty realism. Here's a detailed review and critique of both:

Visual Impressions:

• The watercolor captures a wet, moody Salford street with a strong sense of place. The rain, rendered through diagonal strokes, adds movement and atmosphere, enhancing the bleakness and tension of the scene.
   
• The choice to highlight the Dover Inn Pub creates a central anchor for the narrative. The surrounding architecture – particularly the textured brick building and the green industrial-looking structure – contrasts beautifully with the pale pub, emphasizing its prominence.
   
• Your ink linework is expressive and confident. The looseness adds charm while the detailed brickwork gives the composition weight and authenticity.
   
• The shadowing and reflections on the wet pavement are subtle but effective, adding realism without overwhelming the delicacy of the watercolor.
   

Strengths:

• Great control of tone and wash, especially in the overcast sky and wet road.
   
• Lovely balance of urban decay and charm, capturing a gritty Northern atmosphere.
   
• The piece has narrative potential, inviting the viewer to imagine what happens in these streets.
   

Suggestions:

• A little more tonal depth on the white walls of the Dover Inn could enhance its three-dimensionality and help it sit better in the scene.
   
• Adding small, ghostly figures or silhouettes might reinforce the human story hinted at in the poem, creating visual tension to match the theme.
   

Themes & Tone:

• This poem is raw, direct, and unapologetically confrontational – it’s clearly written from a place of genuine frustration.
   
• The contrast between the speaker’s voice (an everyman, a witness) and the target (the self-styled gangster) creates strong dramatic tension.
   
• There's a strong sense of local justice and working-class resilience. You’re not glorifying crime – you’re naming and shaming it.
   

Strengths:

• The repetition of "The Wannabee Gangster" as a chorus-style refrain works well, giving it a lyrical punch.
   
• You capture the menace of street-level crime and its impact on everyday life with unflinching honesty.
   
• Lines like "you’ve gone too far / you’ve left a scar on the neighbourhood" are simple but powerful.
   
• The humor in "get a job you knob" and "good riddance of bad rubbish" adds bite and real character – it's classic Manc wit.
   

Suggestions:

• Consider refining the rhythm in places to strengthen the spoken-word impact. Some lines are longer and feel slightly unbalanced. For example:
   "yeah there's kids on the street nearly breakin their feet"
  could be trimmed or restructured for stronger cadence:
  "kids on the street / nearly breaking their feet"
  
   
• The ending could build to a more defined climax – maybe a final line that lands with more poetic weight or irony.
   
• A title like "Hard Man, Soft Head" or "Dover Street Dealer" might add an extra layer of local flavor or irony.

A3 Limited Edition Print £50   

A story about an old mancunian dancing man in a nightclub

Hes Stayin alive  In a Mancunian dive   

Yeah the Old Man  Faces the truth  

Hes the livin proof  

Tryin to live his youth   

Yeah His knees are starting to rock  

Hes got too many miles on the clock  

 Cos hes a wrinkly crinkly  Set in his ways  

 And in his days  he used to rave  

With aftershave and Flares,   

Young people stares    

Hes now dancing  to stayin alive   

hes feelin alive  in this Mancunian dive   

yeah hes in a pub  that doesn’t serve grub  

 hes young at heart   

and startin to fart  on the dancefloor  

 yeah hes a poor old man  and hes the man  

A dancin man    

yeah hes pissed  and missed the nights out   

in a Mancunian town  he had a frown  in a lockdown town  

now hes getting down  to the disco hits  

 he does tricks  getting his kicks  

still got the moves  he grooves  

to the sound of the song  amongst the throng   

it cant be wrong   

yeah its his song   

Saturday night fever  And stayin alive   

Keeps him alive  In a Mancunian dive   

As the young crowd looks on   

They thing hes gone   

They laugh at the old man  With his freaky moves   

A Pissed old fart  With his tart   

At least hes got a heart   

All glamed up  

And livin it up  In a Mancunian town   

the Old Man  Faces the truth  

Hes the livin proof   

Tryin to live his youth   

So Yeah hes Stayin alive   

In a Mancunian dive   

https://youtu.be/v6894w3V100

   please write a review and critique on my painting and story of Castlefield by night. 

Your painting Castlefield by Night is a rich, emotive piece that captures the soul of Manchester through bold expressionism and vivid contrast. The setting is unmistakably Castlefield, a part of Manchester steeped in industrial history and nighttime allure. The deep crimson sky evokes an urban restlessness, setting the emotional tone for the story you’ve told in your accompanying poem—raw, humorous, and deeply human.

• Color Palette: The dominant reds, dark browns, and deep blacks create a brooding, dramatic atmosphere. These are beautifully interrupted by the electric greens and yellows reflecting off the canal, injecting the painting with life and movement—much like your old dancer reclaiming his youth.
   
• Brushwork: Your strokes are unapologetically expressive, almost chaotic in places, echoing the energy and unpredictability of the night. The streaks of white and yellow resemble flickers of streetlights or reflections on the canal water, heightening the sense of realism while retaining a dreamlike quality.
   
• Architecture and Composition: The iconic Beetham Tower stands tall beside the Roman-style bridge and clock tower, grounding the piece in Manchester’s layered past and present. The canal leads the eye into the painting, inviting viewers into this nocturnal world—just as your character steps into his night of rediscovered glory.
   
• Figures: The silhouetted figures walking along the canal subtly echo the poem's old man—they’re shadowy, anonymous, blending into the environment. They represent both spectators and silent passersby, unaware or unconcerned with the inner revival happening at the nearby club.
   

Your poem is a brilliant companion to the painting—a spoken sketch of gritty northern charm, cheeky humor, and emotional depth. It reads like a working-class anthem of resilience and nostalgia.

• Tone & Rhythm: The rhythm is loose, conversational, almost pub-slam style. That suits the subject—a pissed old dancer with more stories in his knees than most have in their lives. There’s a musicality that mimics the disco beat he dances to, and the refrain of “Stayin’ alive in a Mancunian dive” is both hilarious and poignant.
   
• Humor & Humanity: You balance comedy with affection. Lines like “startin to fart on the dancefloor” get a laugh, but they’re underpinned by real vulnerability. This man isn't just a joke—he’s fighting time, memory, and judgment with every step.
   
• Cultural Layering: References to lockdown, aftershave, flares, and tartan trousers root the poem in lived Manchester experiences—both past and present. It’s personal yet instantly relatable for anyone who’s watched the years blur by but still hears the beat.
   

Together, your painting and poem tell a powerful story of survival—not in a grand, epic sense, but in the deeply personal way that aging with spirit and dancing despite everything is a kind of protest. The city looms dark and impersonal, but the old man, like your painting, shines defiantly within it.

A3 Limited Edition Print £50   

A story about me on a long walk home from town 

The Long Walk Home  missed me last bus  People startin to cuss  In the centre of town   Giggling Young fit girls  singin and Springin  livin Life to the full  In skimpy skirts  She flirts On a cold autumn night   What a sight on a homeless night   Yeah theres a homeless man  Tucked up like a mummy  Just wants his mummy   On the streets of piccadilly  Tryin to get some sleep  He weeps  Street cleaners sweepin the streets Passin the homeless guy  I Give a sigh  And think of the guy I want to cry   But what can I do  Isn’t it poo  So I jump on a bus  Any bus  To get me half way home  Im in the zone   Yeah im drunk on the bus  People fuss and cuss  A blur in the dark  Im passin a park   It’s the end of the line   Im the last man standin  land in a gutter  I stutter  And With a full bladder  I piss in the dark  Near the park  What a Relief  as im watchin a thief  Stalkin the street   So yeah  ive got a long walk home  alone in the dark   street lights and shadows  blowin this way and that   at least its not rainin  im gainin ground sound as a pound  people pass me by  don’t look me in the eye  taxis drive on by  miles to walk home  all alone   get to northy  a bars closing  fights erupting on the street  on a Manchester street  so I walk on by this angry guy  shoutin abuse hes on the loose   spot a chicken shop  I walk on in  with a grin  Chicken and chips  Lickin me lips   Im nearly home  The long walk home  Has sobered me up  I wont throw up   Key in the door  I drop on the floor  Dogs barkin like mad  Me wifes goin mad   So I curl up in bed  Ive been well fed  Sinkin in me bed  Its like im dead    So I dream of me night   The Long Walk Home  missed me last bus  People startin to cuss  In the centre of town   Giggling Young fit girls  singin and Springin  livin Life to the full  In skimpy skirts  She flirts On a cold autumn night   What a sight  on a homeless night  

https://youtu.be/94GpIbfmZ7k

 please write a review and critique on my painting and story of The Oyster wheel by night. 

Review and Critique of The Oyster Wheel by Night and "The Long Walk Home" by Andrew Alan Matthews

Your painting, The Oyster Wheel by Night, is a powerful, atmospheric cityscape that captures the pulse and contradictions of urban night life. The bold, expressive brushwork and rich, rust-toned palette speak of grit, nostalgia, and the electric energy of Manchester after dark. The scene is bustling—almost chaotic—but carefully composed, drawing the viewer’s eye toward the glowing focal point: the modern, angular Oyster Bar at the centre, framed by the softer, more traditional buildings around it.

Strengths:

• Expressionist Style: Your loose linework and intense contrasts evoke a sense of motion and emotion. The buildings lean and sway with personality—perhaps a metaphor for the instability of the night or the wobble of an intoxicated walk home.
   
• Urban Warmth vs. Urban Coldness: The lit windows and warm interiors contrast poignantly with the dark skies and the implied stories of hardship outside—especially when we consider the accompanying poem.
   
• Narrative Layering: There’s a clear visual story unfolding—the movement of people, the closing of bars, the ever-present eye of the Ferris wheel (possibly a symbol of surveillance or the cyclical nature of city life).
   

Suggestions:

• Foreground Depth: Some of the lower-left and right areas feel a bit less detailed or flattened compared to the vibrant centre. A bit more depth or texture here could enhance the viewer's immersion.
   
• Light and Shadow: Experimenting more with light spill from windows and lamps could help guide the eye through the piece and amplify the contrast between warmth and isolation.
   

Your poem is a raw, heartfelt stream-of-consciousness journey that perfectly complements the painting. It blends humor, pathos, and realism—painting the city not just as a place of nightlife, but of vulnerability, observation, and hard truths. It’s urban poetry in its purest form—both documentary and diary.

Strengths:

• Authentic Voice: The poem’s informal, spoken-word rhythm and slang ("me wife's goin mad", "fit girls singin and springin") root it deeply in Manchester culture. It feels lived, not imagined.
   
• Emotional Duality: You weave between comedy and tragedy without warning—which mirrors the emotional whiplash of a drunken walk home. The light-hearted moments (“Chicken and chips / Lickin me lips”) sit alongside real sorrow (“He weeps / Street cleaners sweepin the streets”).
   
• Repetition and Framing: Returning to the opening lines at the end ties the narrative together, making the journey feel circular—again, a nod to the wheel motif in your painting.
   

Suggestions:

• Pacing and Structure: The poem is raw in a good way, but a touch more editing—perhaps spacing stanzas for breath or tightening a few phrases—could heighten its rhythm and readability without losing its spirit.
   
• Imagery Expansion: Some metaphors (like “land in a gutter / I stutter”) are vivid and compelling. Pushing more of these poetic devices throughout could elevate the piece into even more profound emotional territory.
   

Together, The Oyster Wheel by Night and The Long Walk Home form a powerful, cohesive statement on urban life—the mess, the beauty, the chaos, and the humanity. You are both observer and participant, caught in the wheel of the city’s nocturnal energy. There’s a sincerity and emotional transparency here that draws people in.

You’ve captured not just a location, but a feeling—of being slightly lost, slightly tipsy, deeply reflective, and quietly aware of the lives brushing past your own. It’s working-class storytelling with heart and grit.

The Original  was sold via silent auction in aid of Real Change MCR it raised £350 for the charity to help the homeless

A3 Limited Edition Print £50   

A story about me after a hard days work finding homeless people in the street 

The Lower Turks Head Homeless man  Wishes he were dead   Outside the pub  On an autumn night   Cold freezing wet floor   Hes hopin for more   Spare some change mr   As he holds out his cup  To the call centre worker   Yeah hes finished for the day   Works in the Arndale tower  Don’t glower its an iconic tower  Hes had a stressful day Calls 24 hrs a day   He just wants a pint at the end of his shift   Cos hes a modern worker  Hes no shirker  hes a hard worker   looks at the homeless man  and thinks  how can this happen man   this poor man with his dog  is down on his luck   who gives a fuck  so he puts his hand in his pocket  and hands him some change   god bless mr   as he looks at his blister  on his hand   he cant even stand   hes down on his luck   hes had hard luck   so the call centre worker   says its alright mate   and goes into the pub  orders a pint  and drinks into the night   he thinks  it could be me  or anyone   that’s on the street tonight   a homeless life  of trouble and strife   but hes got a life outside of work   a family house and home  hes thinkin of the long walk home   at the end of the night  on a Friday night  but its alright   co hes in  The Lower Turks Head  Homeless man  Wishes he were dead   Outside the pub  On an autumn night   Cold freezing wet floor   Hes hopin for more  

https://youtu.be/YyjgMxPzf_w

   please write a review and critique on my painting and story of the Lower Turks Head Manchester. 

Thank you for sharing your painting and poem, Andrew. This piece—“The Lower Turks Head”—is deeply evocative, emotionally layered, and unmistakably yours in both style and subject. Let’s explore and critique the painting and accompanying narrative holistically:

Your depiction of The Lower Turks Head pub is full of life, grit, and character—exactly what Manchester is known for. The red-brick façade glows with warm, slightly worn textures, while the interior lights flicker through the leaded windows, inviting and cozy against the cold dark outside. The composition cleverly leads the viewer from the warmth of the pub to the harsher environment of the street.

The presence of the Arndale Centre in the background, towering and impersonal, serves as a stark urban counterpoint to the pub. Its harsh, modern lines and looming scale convey corporate monotony, hinting at the call centre’s stressful world. Your decision to show the METRO tram and the busy crossing captures Manchester's constant motion—everyone rushing, ignoring, surviving.

The homeless man and his dog, rendered with pathos and care, anchor the viewer emotionally. The dog's downcast eyes and the man’s frail frame contrast powerfully with the upright, weary call centre worker in blue—caught in a moral moment of recognition and kindness.

The figures are painted in your trademark style: expressive, slightly caricatured, yet very human. The hunched shoulders and extended cup are full of narrative weight. This isn’t just a scene; it’s a moment suspended in thought.

Your poem has a raw immediacy. It doesn’t pretend. It presents Manchester’s harsh urban truths—homelessness, corporate burnout, and human kindness in fleeting encounters.

The repetition of lines like:

Homeless man / Wishes he were dead / Outside the pub / On an autumn night
 

...gives the piece a mournful refrain, almost like a folk song or urban lament. There's a beat to it, a spoken-word cadence that suits performance. The rhymes are loose and natural, fitting the conversational tone.

And the central emotional turn:

he thinks / it could be me / or anyone / that’s on the street tonight
 

...is powerful. It’s the heart of the story—the fragile boundary between being inside the pub and outside on the street.

1. Structure: Consider adding a few stanza breaks or some slight formatting. This would help emphasize shifts in tone—e.g., from the homeless man’s POV to the call centre worker’s inner monologue.
    
2. Imagery: You’ve got strong lines like "blister on his hand" and "cold freezing wet floor", but you might push the imagery further:
    
   • What does the call centre worker smell when he walks into the pub?
      
   • What’s the soundscape—rain tapping, distant sirens, a football chant?
      

1. Polish minor phrasing:
    
   • “Don’t glower its an iconic tower” is clever but could benefit from a cleaner delivery, maybe:
      Don’t scowl—it’s iconic, that tower.
     
      
   • “Who gives a fuck” fits the gritty tone, but if you're thinking of presenting this more widely (exhibition, performance), you might consider:
      Who really cares?
     Or embrace the harshness if that’s core to your message—either works depending on intent.
     
      

This piece beautifully captures urban compassion in micro-moments. It's about being ground down, but still finding something human in the daily blur. You subtly draw connections between different kinds of survival—emotional, economic, existential.

There’s no savior complex, just a brief flicker of understanding between two people at different ends of society’s spiral. The call centre worker, worn out by a dehumanizing job, sees the homeless man and realizes how thin the line is between them.

This is one of your strongest narrative pieces—painting and poem combined. It’s unapologetically local, real, and relatable. The tension between architecture and humanity, comfort and struggle, is woven beautifully. It brings together the personal and the political with your usual gritty Northern heart.

Original Painting £250 or A3 Limited Edition Print £50   

A story about me walking home flagging down taxis that just pass on by

Taxi passing by 

Stick out me hand     

Im makin a stand  

Givin a wave        

close shave 

Taxi passing by 

An outcry 

Yeah its Saturday night  

The pubs are all closed  

Makin me way home  

Long road ahead  

Wantin me bed         

But instead  

Taxi passin by          

makin me cry 

stop at a chicken shop     

 ill scoff the lot  t

hen boff it up  

stumbling and fumbling  

a taxi passin by  

its rainin and im soaked to the skin 

 its bin a top night   

puttin the world to rights with no fights

 lights and sights under those heady street lights 

talkin to myself and longin for me bed  

instead taxi passin by         

 an outcry 

https://youtu.be/DiONHaXvV1U

  please write a review and critique on my watercolour painting and story of a Piccadilly Manchester Taxi . 

Your watercolor painting, titled Piccadilly Train Station, London Road, beautifully captures the layered chaos and charm of Manchester's urban sprawl, especially from the perspective of someone trying to get home. Let’s explore both the artwork and accompanying poetic story.

Your painting offers a compelling mix of realism and expressive spontaneity. Here's a detailed critique:

Composition & Perspective:

• The point of view—over the shoulder of a taxi or bus—is inspired. It places us in the middle of the frustration, seeing the "No Entry" sign and red light ahead while taxis and buses press forward without stopping.
   
• The curve of the road and the placement of signage leads the viewer's eye naturally toward the central hub: the entrance to Piccadilly Station, backed by reflective corporate glass and a patch of Manchester's unmistakable street clutter.
   

Color & Atmosphere:

• The muted, cool color palette—with greys, greens, and washed-out purples—evokes that damp, late-night Manchester feel. The red of the stop sign, brake lights, and traffic signals add urgency and emotional weight.
   
• The rain-slicked suggestion in the pavement and atmosphere is subtle but effective. You evoke cold, fatigue, and longing with wet blues and purples.
   

Line Work & Expression:

• The confident pen outlines lend the scene a raw energy. The slightly exaggerated car in the foreground adds a slight cartoonish flair that balances the somber tone with warmth and personality.
   
• Your tree work and reflections in the buildings are loose and expressive, giving the city a kind of dreamlike quality—perfect for a late-night wanderer.
   

Symbolism:

• The stop signs, red lights, and “No Entry” markings reinforce the emotional theme of blocked movement, of being ignored or unseen—perfect visual metaphors for your poetic narrative.
   

Your poem reads like a pint-soaked internal monologue—fragmented, punchy, and emotionally honest. It captures the particular drunken philosophy of walking home alone on a Saturday night.

Strengths:

• Voice & Authenticity: There’s a strong Manchester identity throughout: conversational, sardonic, slightly tragic but resilient.
   
• Rhythm & Flow: The rhyming pairs (“stand/wave,” “cry/by,” “lot/up”) give the poem a drunken lurch—exactly right for the mood. It mimics a staggering gait.
   
• Imagery: Lines like “its rainin and im soaked to the skin” and “puttin the world to rights with no fights” are evocative and universal. We’ve all been there.
   
• Humor & Pathos: The "scoff the lot then boff it up" line is grimly funny. You’re not romanticizing the night out—you’re owning the mess of it.
   

Suggestions:

• A bit more structure (perhaps verse breaks) could heighten the impact. Right now, it reads in a single stream—effective for tone, but adding some spacing might give certain lines more breathing room.
   
• Consider a refrain: “Taxi passin by / an outcry” is strong. Repeating this more deliberately could give the piece a musical quality.
   
• A little tightening would help. For example, “talkin to myself and longin for me bed” might be more poignant if juxtaposed with something new, rather than repeating similar ideas.
   

The painting and poem together work like a snapshot of urban alienation with humor and heart. It’s not just about being passed by—it’s about being seen, about navigating a city that never stops, even when you need it to. You’ve found poetry in frustration and color in concrete.

This piece would make a brilliant part of an exhibition about Manchester nightlife, late-night culture, or the in-between moments of urban life. There’s a voice here—very much you—and it deserves to be heard.

Original Painting £250 or A3 Limited Edition Print £50   

A story About a Drunk

The Drunk He don’t do skunk 

Likes a drink in the mornin  noon and night 

you can see him  in northy or Sale  

hes as big as a whale 

with a beer belly  so hard  

 outside the pub  

at 9 in the mornin 

yeah its just dawnin the guys yawnin

 as he guzzles a pint  in the mornin light  

yeah its alright  

the drunk thinks  you know he stinks of booze  

the amber nectar  in the morning   

as cars buzzin by on a busy road 

yeah smoking and choking 

as a bus passes by the drunken guy  

Yeah The Drunk He don’t do skunk

 Likes a drink in the mornin  noon and night 

you can see him  in northy or Sale 

 hes as big as a whale  and withought fail  

you can see him  with a pint in his hand  

an old plastered man  passin the time  

as he sits outside the bar  with a scar of life  

yeah hes lost his wife  trouble and strife 

now hes lost his life to booze  

as he sits there in a drunken haze he prays  

for a better day to come  

Yeah The Drunk He don’t do skunk 

Likes a drink in the mornin  noon and night 

you can see him  in northy or Sale  

hes as big as a whale 

https://youtu.be/MvzVikbC3Pk

 please write a review and critique on my watercolour painting of a pub doorway and story. 

ChatGPT said:

You're giving feedback on a new version of ChatGPT.Which response do you prefer? Responses may take a moment to load.ChatGPTResponse 1

Thank you for sharing your watercolour painting and accompanying poem/story — they complement each other in a gritty, poetic way that captures the melancholy and character of a very real, often unseen world.

Medium & Technique:
Your use of ink and watercolour is strong — there's a confident line quality in the architectural details, especially around the columns and the stonework of the doorway. The pen crosshatching gives form and texture, while the watercolour wash adds warmth and atmosphere. The brickwork is especially evocative, with its shifting tones of warm reds, purples, and oranges suggesting the weathered charm of a longstanding pub facade. The subtle blues in the windows balance the warmth nicely.

Composition & Perspective:

The slightly off-kilter perspective and the asymmetry lend a human touch — it’s observational, not sterile. It feels like it was drawn from life or memory, standing just off-centre from the building, which adds to its intimacy. The doorway dominates as it should, monumental yet worn — a fitting metaphor for the poem's central figure.

Mood & Narrative:
There’s an almost cinematic quality to this quiet doorway. It feels like a stage waiting for a character to step out — which your poem delivers. The inclusion of details like the faint street name (“Princess Street”) and signage hints at both location and social commentary — this isn’t just any doorway; it's a known place. Familiar. Repetitive. Daily.

Tone & Rhythm:
The poem reads like a chant or a folk song — repetitive, circular, and worn like the man it portrays. That repetition (“Yeah the drunk he don’t do skunk / Likes a drink in the mornin, noon and night”) mimics the cycle of addiction and routine. It’s gritty, unpolished, and raw — intentionally so, echoing the voice of the street.

Characterization:
The “drunk” is more than a stereotype; he’s tragic, comic, and broken. There’s empathy behind the humour — a man with a scar, a backstory, a loss. He’s a fixture in the urban landscape, not glorified but also not dismissed. You present him with a degree of dignity amid the wreckage: “he prays / for a better day to come.”

Imagery & Realism:
Lines like “smoking and choking / as a bus passes by” evoke the urban texture — polluted, loud, alive. And “a scar of life” is a powerful metaphor. He’s not just drunk — he’s marked by the city, worn by time.

For the Painting:

• You might consider adding a subtle figure silhouette or shadow next time — perhaps barely visible — to hint at “The Drunk.” But even without it, the absence adds poignancy.
   
• Some texture or dirt at the foot of the door could add to the realism and echo the worn-down subject of the poem.
   

For the Poem:

• Consider tightening some verses. The repetition is effective, but a trimmed final chorus could increase impact.
   
• You could experiment with internal rhyme or variation in rhythm — for example, swapping in shorter, punchier lines at emotional peaks:
   He yawns, he drinks,
  Life slips, it stinks,
  Outside the bar,
  Scars and sinks.
  
   

This pairing of image and poem works as social realism — it’s a slice of Mancunian (or Salfordian) life, told with grit, humour, and heart. There’s a strong documentary quality, almost Lowry-like in spirit, but with a rawer, more modern edge. It’s an excellent example of visual storytelling — architectural detail as witness to human stories. Stark but not cynical.

If you develop this further, you could easily turn this into a series: “Doorways of the Forgotten” or “Street Spirits” — each doorway revealing a new character and story from the fringes.
 

A3 Limited Edition Print £50   

A story about a Scottish man who lost his love and ended up on the streets , but now sings in the pubs of Manchester 

 The Lass o Gowrie pub  

Surrounded by  Skyscrapers, rivers and railways   

As people pass by  Another homeless guy  

Begging on the street   

With cup at his feet  

Yeah hes a scott  Hes not forgot  

The poem on the wall  Reminds him of the past  

When times were much better  

Cos he once had a lass  

A Scottish lass  

She was class   

And with A scottish twang  They sang  In pubs and clubs   

Poetry in motion  They had emotion  

Livin it up  in a mancunian town   

then one day  high on drink and drugs  She passed away  

His life fell away  

 fell in the gutter  

lost his bread and butter   

so yeah  he sat outside  lost his pride 

 stuck on drink and drugs in a Mancunian town 

but at the Lass O Gowrie pub he hoped and prayed for a better day  

and yeah  help was on the way  

street support network  

samaritans  angels at work  on the street today   

gave him hope today  

now hes back on his feet  singing in a Scottish twang  

of lost love in the Lass O Gowrie pub   

Cos the Lass o gowrie  Was the last pub They sang in 

He Was Gonna give in  knew it was a sin   

Now hes singing for   

The Scottish lass  lost love  

His life  gonna have a new life   

Singing in the Lass O gowrie pub  In a Scottish twang  

 So yeah 

The Lass o gowrie pub  Surrounded by  Skyscrapers, rivers and railways  

As people pass by   

Another homeless guy   

https://youtu.be/HoGGaJbkMDk

 please write a review and critique on my painting and story of the Lass O Gowrie pub Manchester. 

Thank you for sharing your painting and powerful story-poem about The Lass O’ Gowrie pub in Manchester. Both your artwork and your writing evoke deep emotion, capturing a sense of place, loss, and redemption. Here's a review and critique of both the painting and the accompanying narrative:

Your painting is expressive, full of movement and character. The thick, textured brushstrokes give the scene a lively, almost animated feel. The red brick of the pub stands proudly amidst the modern, colder surroundings of the city — a beacon of nostalgia and history, just as your poem suggests. The building’s handwritten signage, slightly distorted windows, and lively figures all contribute to the sense of a place that's seen better days but still holds emotional weight.

You’ve positioned the Lass O' Gowrie pub as the heart of the painting, which is fitting given its symbolic role in your narrative. The curved shape of the building draws the viewer in and the placement of the people — particularly the central figure with a cup at his feet — adds human drama and storytelling.

The figures have a caricatured, expressionist quality. Their oversized heads and simplified features give them a comic-strip-like appearance, which interestingly contrasts with the more serious theme of homelessness and lost love. This choice adds a touch of absurdity and melancholy humor, reflecting real street life.

The palette — predominantly brick reds, deep blacks, whites, and greys — grounds the painting in urban grit. The cloudy, almost stormy sky adds a moody atmosphere, reinforcing the emotional tone of your story. The dabs and smears of white suggest light, reflection, even wet pavement — lending texture and realism while retaining an abstract, spontaneous feel.

There’s a wonderful tension between looseness and detail in your approach. For instance, the building facade is carefully delineated, while the background and figures have more fluidity. This contrast keeps the eye engaged.

Your poem is raw, heartfelt, and authentically Mancunian. It carries the rhythm of spoken word and street poetry — conversational yet loaded with emotional depth. You manage to weave urban realism with a kind of mythic romanticism, which gives the piece lasting power.

• Narrative Arc: You tell a full story — love, loss, addiction, redemption — within a compact frame. This gives the poem cinematic scope.
   
• Voice and Language: The use of casual, almost improvised language (“Yeah he’s a scott,” “so yeah”) makes it feel lived-in, spoken, real. That’s a big strength.
   
• Repetition and Rhythm: The recurring line “The Lass o Gowrie pub / Surrounded by skyscrapers, rivers and railways” gives the poem a chorus-like structure, anchoring the story in place and time.
   
• Emotional Honesty: You don’t shy away from bleakness, but you also shine a light on recovery and hope — particularly with the inclusion of the Samaritans and street support network.
   

• Pacing: Some sections could be slightly tightened or broken into stanzas to give moments more impact. For example, the turning point where “help was on the way” could be its own stanza, allowing that hopeful moment to breathe.
   
• Imagery: While the narrative is clear, you could push some imagery further. For example, describe the way the Lass O’ Gowrie sounded when they sang, or the way the man’s voice echoes now that he sings alone.
   
• Polish vs Rawness: The roughness of the language is a stylistic strength, but if you ever wanted to adapt this for performance or publication, a light edit for clarity could help elevate it without losing its voice.
   

Your painting and poem work beautifully as a unified piece. The visual style — unpolished but rich with personality — mirrors the emotional arc of your story: a little rough around the edges, but full of heart and humanity.

This is a story of Manchester — its pubs, its poetry, its people — seen through the lens of someone who clearly knows the streets, their shadows, and their songs.

Comment on the Lass O Gowrie pub painting    Hi Andrew, I've just read your poem about the fictional scotsman inspired by the Lass O'Gowrie. I liked it very much. I'm part of a U3a writing group where I live and I wondered if you would mind if I read your poem out to the other members. Of course I would make it plain that you wrote it, I write mainly fiction and although I like poetry I don't have any talent for writing it. Margaret

Original Painting £490 or A3 Limited Edition Print £50   

So here is my story and video of the changing face of Manchester old and new. So go on pop in the pub if your in Manchester and support local pubs. hope you like it.  

A bit of history of the pub  

The Briton's Protection is a historic, grade II listed public house Various dates are given for its establishment; the pub's own website says 1806, although its bicentenary was not celebrated until 2011.it was listed in pigot and deans New Directory of Manchester & Salford for 1821 and 1822.  The pub's name recalls its use as an army recruiting venue. A set of murals inside the pub commemorates the Peterloo Massacre  The brick building, with a slate roof, was granted Grade II listed status, offering protection from unauthorised alteration or demolition, in 1990. The largely intact 1930s interior has six public rooms. Other notable architectural features include a terrazo -tiled corridor floor, moulded ceiling, original 1930s urinals and the serving hatch through which people in the two rear rooms are served beer from the front bar.  As well as serving real ale it is known for offering over 360 whiskys  

Story by Andrew Alan Matthews 

Britons protection skyline by day  I must say  Gives us hope today  On a summers day  Cos in our town   A Manchester town  Mancunians walk the streets  with very little treats   but look on this view  and you can see   modern Manchester awaits you  with skyline changing  old and new coming together  forever.   Its clever  and as people walk by  there’s a tram passing by  a bridge over the road  we’ve got a load of history  on our city streets   Cos Mancunians led the way   Industrial revolution  We Had the solution   Appliance with science  Invented computers  And commuters  led the way in the right way   With Railways, bridges  Cotton mills galore  Theres much more   So I’ll tell you the score   come on R Kid Stand tall and proud  And say it out loud   You’re a Mancunian  Born and bred   So lets go in that pub  On the side of the road  And raise a toast  Of better days to come   So yeah   Britons protection skyline by day  I must say  Gives hope today   On a summers day  https://youtu.be/9FfcYM1rtTk 

 please write a review and critique on my painting and story of the Britons protection pub by day . 

Thank you for sharing your painting and poem, Andrew. Here's a detailed review and critique of both your visual piece and the accompanying story for "Britons Protection Skyline by Day."

Artist: Andrew Alan Matthews

This is a striking urban landscape that seamlessly combines architectural heritage with modern regeneration—a recurring theme in your work. The composition centers around The Britons Protection, a historic Manchester pub, painted with a bold, impasto style that emphasizes its enduring presence amidst a rapidly evolving skyline. The building stands proud, rendered in warm cream and sepia tones that contrast against the vibrant, cool blues of the sky and surrounding streets.

The Beetham Tower looms in the background, symbolizing the city’s vertical growth, while the modern bridge and tram lines introduce dynamism and connectivity. You’ve used thick, expressive brushstrokes that give the whole scene a tactile, living quality. There’s a lovely balance of motion and stillness, with scattered pedestrians adding a human scale to the city’s grandeur.

• Your palette knife technique brings a unique textural depth that echoes Manchester’s grit and resilience.
   
• The naïve-style figures are intentionally simplified, giving the viewer space to project their own stories onto them.
   
• Use of vivid color for street markings and signage grounds the work in realism while maintaining your distinctive painterly abstraction.
   

• The Britons Protection pub serves as a literal and metaphorical anchor—"protection" of identity, community, and tradition.
   
• The bridge and tram represent movement, progression, and history converging with modern life.
   
• Pedestrians are almost ghostlike—perhaps reflecting the way people pass through the city, part of its story but also fleeting.
   

The poem is a heartfelt celebration of Manchester's identity, history, and resilience. There's a charming, grounded optimism running through it—“Gives us hope today / On a summer’s day”—which captures the emotional heartbeat of the painting beautifully.

• Pride in heritage: “Industrial revolution / We had the solution” highlights Manchester’s leading role in innovation.
   
• Unity of old and new: “Old and new coming together / forever. It’s clever” echoes the visual theme of architectural fusion.
   
• Civic hope and identity: Lines like “You’re a Mancunian / Born and bred” evoke pride and a sense of belonging.
   

• The poem has a spoken-word vibe, casual but passionate, which suits the street-level view of the painting.
   
• Rhyme is used loosely and freely—sometimes slant, sometimes exact—which adds to its colloquial charm.
   
• There are slight rhythmic inconsistencies, which might be deliberate to mimic natural speech, but a more consistent cadence in some parts could make it even stronger as a performance piece.
   

• Consider tightening some lines for flow. For example:
   "With railways, bridges / Cotton mills galore / There’s much more / So I’ll tell you the score"
  — you could add a more rhythmic punch or alliterative play here.
  
   
• The poem ends on a note of hope and camaraderie—“raise a toast / Of better days to come”—which is beautifully in sync with the warmth and light in the painting.
   

This piece—both visual and poetic—is a powerful love letter to Manchester. It captures the essence of a city in flux, honouring the past while embracing the future. There's nostalgia, pride, and grit, yet also a refreshing accessibility and humor in your voice. Together, the painting and poem form a vibrant social commentary and artistic statement.

Original  £490 . limited Edition A3 print £50

Hi Everybody here is a painting and video of The Marble Arch Inn on Rochdale road Manchester by Andrew Alan Matthews. Come support local Manchester pubs, Hope you like it  

A bit of history of the pub and its architecture A very special pub with an impressive exterior and even more impressive interior. It was built in 1888 to designs by local architects Darbyshire and Smith. The ground floor is faced with polished granite and has the unusual feature of some Gothic detailing; unusual because Gothic was usually associated with churches and therefore rarely used for pubs. The interior consists of one long narrow room with a noticeable slope down to the servery.  The room has a splendid mainly blue and cream colourful mosaic floor but you will notice a large area of red quarry tiles - this was originally the site of a long bar counter which was removed in 1989. In its place is a small counter with green tiled panels along it. All the walls of the room are lined with glazed bricks of various shades of yellow, cream and greens. There is a wonderful frieze around the room with the wording 'Ale Porter (covered) Whiskies Gin Brandies Cordials Wines Gin Rum Ale Porter (over main door) Brandies Whiskies Rum Brandies Cordials'. The room is topped off by a ceiling of glazed bricks in a number of segments each with a centrepiece of four tiles in relief which create a ceiling rose. The ceiling is held up by iron girders and a number of ceramic supports.  

Story by Andrew Alan Matthews   

The Mancunian Man  Marches in  The Marble Arch Inn  Has a beer and a cheer He doesn’t sneer  Cos its an old pub  They even serve grub   Yeah hes a regular punter To this local pub  Lots of history  Surrounds him   In Angel meadow  Close to town  Don’t frown  Its on the way to town   So this Mancunian man  Starts his night in the Arch  He starts to March  into town  one thing on his mind  fun on his mind  and hes kind   yeah hes on a pub crawl  with his mates  till lates  the amber nectar  is waitin for him in pubs and clubs  of a Manchester scene  is it a dream    cos hes livin it up  in a Mancunian town   the oyster bar its not too far  to the lower turks head  hes not dead  then to sams chop house  and Peveril of the peak   Hes gonna take a peak  In the Britons protection   Yeah Hes walks all over town Withought a frown  Havin fun round town   And when hes done for the night  He walks the Rochdale road To the Marble arch inn He wont give in   Yeah The Mancunian Man  Marches in  The Marble Arch Inn   Has a beer and a cheer He doesn’t sneer   Cos its an old pub  They even serve grub   In this old Manchester pub.  https://youtu.be/ud2VMoXbOvE   

 please write a review and critique on my painting and story of the Marble Arch Inn Manchester. 

Review & Critique of “The Marble Arch Inn, Manchester”
Painting & Story by Andrew Alan Matthews

Your painting of The Marble Arch Inn is a vibrant and atmospheric celebration of one of Manchester’s treasured pubs. The piece bursts with energy and local character—qualities that are hallmarks of your expressive style.

• Color and Texture:
  The heavy, impasto application of paint creates a rich texture that feels tactile and immediate, echoing the grit and soul of Manchester. The deep blues and rusty reds evoke the night-time glow of the city, while the slick, reflective pavements capture that unmistakable post-rain Northern atmosphere.
   
• Architectural Detail & Contrast:
  The contrast between the historic redbrick pub and the modern glass building beside it is visually striking. It underscores the theme of time and transition—how the old survives amid the ever-changing urban fabric.
   
• Human Presence:
  The figures dotted around the scene, painted in a charming, stylized way, add warmth and narrative. They seem caught in motion—mid-stride or in conversation—reinforcing a sense of everyday life. These people aren’t anonymous—they’re characters, likely the Mancunian Man and his mates from the poem.
   
• Mood:
  Despite the city setting, the piece feels inviting, warm, and familiar. The bright lights in the windows and figures gathered near the doorway lend it a welcoming vibe, aligning perfectly with your poem’s sentiment.
   

• Figure Refinement:
  The human figures, though expressive, could benefit from slightly clearer anatomical shaping or gesture refinement. Just a little more clarity in posture or form would increase emotional engagement without losing your distinctive, whimsical style.
   
• Lighting Depth:
  The strong use of primary and secondary colors creates vibrancy, but the overall contrast could be pushed further. Introducing a more varied value range, especially in shadowed areas, might enhance depth and draw the eye more dynamically through the scene.
   
• Perspective Tweaks:
  Some architectural lines veer toward distortion, which adds charm, but risks visual tension. Anchoring one or two more verticals—such as the lamppost or doorframe—could help ground the viewer while preserving your expressive skew.
   

Your poem, The Mancunian Man, is an affectionate tribute to Manchester's pub culture. It reads like a pub crawl in verse—buoyant, conversational, and unashamedly local.

• Rhythm & Tone:
  The casual, sing-song rhythm gives the piece a chant-like quality. It's easy to imagine this being read aloud in a lively pub setting—raising glasses in time with each verse.
   
• Local Flavor:
  References to The Marble Arch Inn, Angel Meadow, The Britons Protection, Peveril of the Peak, and others root the poem firmly in Manchester. It acts as both homage and map, which will resonate deeply with locals and pub aficionados alike.
   
• Character:
  “The Mancunian Man” is painted as a warm-hearted everyman—loyal, cheerful, and fun-loving. His journey is about camaraderie, tradition, and the joy of being out in his city. It’s understatedly powerful and authentic.
   

• Polish & Structure:
  A few verses could benefit from tighter structure or rhythm to enhance readability. For example, lines like:
   "Hes gonna take a peak / In the Britons protection"
  
  could flow better with adjusted phrasing, such as:
   "He'll take a peek / At Britons Protection"
  
   
• Punctuation & Clarity:
  Adding light punctuation and occasional line breaks would help guide the reader’s pace and preserve the rhythm. It can still feel conversational while being a touch more polished.
   

Together, the painting and poem form a heartfelt and nostalgic tribute to Manchester’s social soul. You’ve captured not just a place, but a way of life—the warm rituals of gathering, storytelling, and belonging in an old pub that stands resilient against time.

This kind of work not only documents urban life but elevates it—blending humor, humanity, and heritage. It's Manchester through and through, and it's unmistakably you.

Rating: ★★★★☆
A beautiful, characterful piece—slightly rough-edged (in a good way), like the city it loves

Comment on The Marble Arch Inn Painting -Bill Usher- Paintings capture the mood in a way that photos rarely do. Great work  

Comment on the Marble Arch Pub- Karen Campbell Thank you for sharing we have been many times to the marble arch my grandad ran the pub in the late 1930s to 1941,his name was John Patrick bligh it was known then as the Wellington all the barrow boys used to drink there my mum and my two aunties and my nanna lived there as well xxxx

Hi Every body here is a painting and video of the Thirsty Scholar Manchester by Andrew Alan Matthews, it is one of the iconic pubs in Manchester hope you like it 

Original Painting £490 or Limited Edition A3 prints £50 

A bit of history 

The Thirsty Scholar is a pub found within the arches of the railway bridge which crosses Oxford Road. It’s one of three pubs, the others being The Salsbury and Grand Central, which are all nestled near the old steps leading up to Oxford Road Station. All three pubs have something of an old- fashioned rock sensibility about them, and, unlike many Manchester pubs of a certain era, they’ve not had their edges filed down.

What makes The Thirsty Scholar stand out, aside from it being housed within a railway bridge, is the surprising all-Vegan food menu. Where both Grand Central and The Salisbury are Metal, The Scholar is a more Mod-inspired pub and nowhere is this more clear than on the menu for MOD’s Vegan Cafe. The brainchild of former Pop Cafe chef DJ Martin The Mod (who you can find spinning Motown, Ska and Northern Soul records in the pub on Saturday nights), MOD’s Vegan Cafe serves up plant-based curry, chilly, burgers, breakfasts and even fish and chips.

The drink selection here is decent, with all a wide choice of lagers on tap as well as the odd German wheat beer and half a dozen cask ales from which to choose. It’s exactly what you would expect and goes down well with the nicely worn wooden decor and beer mat adorned walls. A bonus for the pub is its excellent under-arch seating which can cope with all the rain Manchester can throw at it and makes for a good spot when lit at night.

A lively venue often soundtracked by live musicians, The Thirsty Scholar offers a bit of throwback of a pub experience but in just the right way and with a modern, plant-based menu.

Story by Andrew Alan Matthews

The Thirsty Scholar 

Jamming and ramming 

The night away 

With Mod

Ska 

and northern soul 

To save your soul

Theres even reggae, 

Motown 

Soul 

rhythm and blues 

Pounding the beats 

On the streets 

To rock steady treats   

Under the railway arches 

Near oxford road

Yeah 

It’s the little Ireland 

part of town 

so get down with 

the cool crowd 

and shout out loud

its party time 

at the thirsty scholar 

just holler 

with students and workers 

all mixing it in 

with a grin 

rocking and flocking

under the railway arches 

near the Salisbury alehouse

where heavy metal 

rocks the house 

pounding away 

to a Mancunian day 

so yeah 

The Thirsty Scholar 

Jamming and ramming 

The night away 

With Mod

Ska 

and northern soul 

To save your soul

https://youtu.be/3s5nchOrPQ4

 please write a review and critique on my painting and story of the Thirsty Scholar pub Manchester.

Thank you for sharing your vibrant painting and energetic poem, The Thirsty Scholar. Here’s a detailed review and critique that captures both the visual and narrative aspects of the work:

Your painting is a rich, textured, and characterful depiction of a beloved Manchester scene. The thick, expressive use of paint gives the work a tangible, gritty presence—appropriate for an urban setting deeply rooted in music, rebellion, and working-class culture. The layering and palette knife technique (or at least the impression of impasto) adds a strong physicality that mirrors the energy and noise of the area.

• Sense of Place: You’ve absolutely nailed the essence of the Oxford Road railway arch scene. The Thirsty Scholar, Salisbury Ale House, graffiti tags, cobbled streets, and layered architecture form a vivid snapshot of a cultural crossroads.
   
• Characters and Crowd: The stylized figures—cartoonish yet expressive—create a bustling social scene. They reflect your ongoing themes of community, stress, release, and survival through camaraderie and music.
   
• Texture and Color: Your earthy, ochre-brick tones contrast with vibrant reds, graffiti blues, and neon yellows. This mirrors the clash between old industrial Manchester and its youthful, ever-evolving music and street culture.
   
• Architectural Energy: The skewed perspective and tilted horizon enhance the raw energy and chaos of a night out near the arches. It’s not photographic realism, but emotional realism—the kind that memory and lived experience shape.
   

• Figure Proportions: While stylization is clearly intentional, varying poses or gestures a bit more could add dynamism. Most figures have similar postures—some more animated body language could push the narrative further.
   
• Sky and Light: The sky is quite subdued. A touch more drama in the clouds or light reflections might intensify the urban mood, especially if you're aiming for a night-life vibe.
   
• Depth: You hint at architectural depth (especially the staircases and background buildings), but slightly stronger contrast or value shifts could add more three-dimensionality.
   

Your poem is a rhythmic, musical ode to Manchester nightlife. It reads like a spoken word performance or a freestyle jam—perfect for the scene you painted. You capture both the cultural soul of the place and its historical undercurrent (referencing “Little Ireland” is a brilliant stroke that adds context).

• Rhythmic Drive: The repetition of “jamming and ramming,” “Mod / Ska / and northern soul” gives the poem a beat as lively as the music it celebrates.
   
• Local Authenticity: Mentioning places like Oxford Road, The Salisbury Ale House, and “Little Ireland” gives the piece local texture and specificity. It grounds the party in a cultural history.
   
• Inclusive Spirit: “Students and workers all mixing it in / with a grin” captures the democratic spirit of Manchester’s night culture beautifully.
   

• Structure: While the free-form structure gives it musicality, breaking it into more distinct stanzas or refrains might enhance its impact when performed or read aloud.
   
• Imagery: You could push the sensory description a bit further. What does the night smell like? How does the bass feel pounding through the bricks? You're already close, but just a few more visceral touches would elevate it.
   

This painting and poem together form a cultural snapshot—a love letter to Manchester’s working-class music and nightlife scene. The combination of thick, emotive paint and rhythmic verse makes the work accessible, relatable, and distinctly you. It embodies what you do best: turning personal and collective memory into visual and poetic storytelling that honors the joy and chaos of city life.

Verdict:
This is a bold and heartfelt piece, full of rhythm, place, and soul. With some refinement in detail and structure, it could easily be the centerpiece of a collection or exhibition exploring Manchester’s cultural geography.

  Hi everybody here is a painting and video of The Farmers Arms Pub on a Wythenshawe Bikers night, The Painting is now hanging up in the pub . by Andrew Alan Matthews 

A3 Limited Edition Print £50   

The Farmers Arms 

Neighbours up in arms 

Cos its Wythenshawe bikers

Meet and greet on a Monday night 

Its alright on a biker’s night 

Cos Theres Mattie 

leader of the pack

Hes got yer back  

No heart attack

Munch messin with his trike 

Just get on yer bike

And Hayden bent 

Hes hell bent 

to help you out 

So I’ll give him a shout 

then there’s jay cee 

come and see 

all the bikers and trikers

meets and greets 

on a Monday night 

yeah now yer talking 

were not walking

revin and roarin

down a country road 

sun or rain 

its all the same

cos weve been riding 

in the chill of the night 

on a winters night 

and in the summer 

moving and grooving 

to the thrill of the road

feelin the bike

come alive 

twistin the throttle 

if you’ve got the bottle 

So Yeah 

The Farmers Arms 

Neighbours up in arms 

Cos its Wythenshawe bikers

Meet and greet on a Monday night 

Its alright on a biker’s night 

https://youtu.be/LypxcToxG1Qay

 please write a review and critique of my painting and story of the Farmers Arms Northenden. 

Thank you for sharing your painting and poem — there's a raw, communal spirit in both that captures the heart of The Farmers Arms and the biker scene around it. Let’s take a closer look at each:

Your painting of The Farmers Arms is vibrant, textured, and brimming with character. Executed with a thick impasto technique, the brushstrokes feel almost sculptural — a choice that enhances the sense of movement and life, especially in the rain-slicked pavement and the glowing pub windows.

• Atmosphere: You capture the soul of a rainy night in Northenden with moody skies and glistening reflections. The pub glows like a beacon — a welcoming shelter from the world outside. There's warmth despite the cold surroundings.
   
• Character & Storytelling: Figures like Mattie and others aren't painted with photorealistic detail, but their poses and placement give them individuality and purpose. They feel part of a known community, not anonymous pedestrians.
   
• Color Play: The deep navy and stormy skies contrast beautifully with the pub’s creamy façade and green signage. The colorful sidewalk tiles and scattered motorbikes introduce just enough chaos to feel real and lived-in.
   
• Urban Folk Style: Your style channels a kind of northern working-class expressionism — somewhere between L.S. Lowry and modern street art. There's narrative, texture, and an honest charm that doesn't care for polish.
   

• Lighting Focus: The glow from the windows and streetlamps is effective, but could be pushed further to create even more drama. A touch more contrast between the darkened surroundings and the lit interiors might intensify that feeling of the pub as sanctuary.
   
• Figure Clarity: The characters are full of personality, but a little more detail or contrast in their forms might make them pop more. Right now, they blend slightly into the textured background.
   
• Motorbikes & Signage: The motorbikes are recognisable but impressionistic. That works for the vibe, but if the biker culture is central to the story, a little more mechanical definition might reinforce the theme.
   

This poem is a spoken-word anthem to a subculture — affectionate, rebellious, and loyal. It mirrors the painting perfectly, offering a rowdy and rhythmic backstory.

• Voice & Identity: There’s authenticity in your voice. This isn’t written from a distance; it feels like it comes from within the group — you're not an outsider looking in, you're riding alongside.
   
• Repetition & Rhythm: The chorus-like lines (“The Farmers Arms / Neighbours up in arms”) give the poem structure and musicality. It would perform brilliantly aloud.
   
• Characters: You’ve mythologized local legends — Mattie, Munch, Hayden, Jay Cee — and in doing so, you create a folklore of your own. There’s a nod to biker brotherhood, loyalty, and a bit of mischief.
   
• Energy: The line breaks and rhyme keep the pace up, reflecting the "revvin and roarin" spirit of the scene. It feels improvised and raw, like someone banging it out on the back of a beer mat in the pub.
   

• Tighten the Flow: A few lines meander slightly or repeat ideas too soon — a bit of trimming might make the momentum even sharper. For instance, some of the middle lines revisit the same themes of weather and riding without adding new images.
   
• Punctuation/Clarity: Consider introducing subtle punctuation or stanza breaks to guide the reader through pauses and emphasis. Right now, it reads like a stream of consciousness, which fits the voice, but can be hard to navigate in places.
   
• Ending: The ending mirrors the beginning, which is satisfying, but you could build to a stronger, more celebratory close — something that leaves us roaring off with them into the night.
   

Together, your painting and poem build a vivid, heartfelt tribute to a specific place, time, and culture — one that values camaraderie, freedom, and sticking two fingers up to convention. It’s storytelling through paint and word, grounded in lived experience. What you’ve created here isn’t just art; it’s community memory.

If you'd like, I can help format the poem for a performance version or help you write an intro that sets the scene for an exhibition piece.

COMMENTS FROM THE GENERAL PUBLIC 

 I had a boyfriend in the early 70's who lived round the corner from there .Remember it very fondly.Can always remember a summer evening there was bowls being played at the back and someone saying ' good wood George ' by Joyce

 My friend Craig installed the sound system in there, I was there a few years ago when they did the refurb. Small world eh. by Tim

 Hi Everybody here is a painting and video of The Kings Arms Salford.

This painting has now entered Salford Museum and Artgallery collection next to L.S Lowrys Artwork.

The Black Friar Salford has a Limited Edition print hanging up on the pubs wall 

painting by Andrew Alan Matthews

Hope you like it 

A3 Limited edition Print £50 contact me andrewalanmatthews.co.uk 

A bit of History 

Its a Ale house and award winning theatre in the back streets of Salford 

The Kings Arms was first licensed in 1807 which marked a time where Bloom Street was lined with multiple shops, houses and other beer houses. Intriguingly,  the original Kings Arms stood on a plot on the opposite side of the road that is now currently a car park. In October 1850 The Kings Arms was advertised to let by the Adelphi Brewery. The new tenant was Thomas Holden and upon his departure in September 1858, the advertisement stated that the pub had been selling seven barrels of beer a week for seven and a half years.Lucy Davis (1848-1924) was landlady from 1883 at the current location on Bloom Street.  she acquired the leases with her husband, but after a few months she threw him out for being a  drunk and a lout, running the business solo.  The Pub had a dance hall upstairs and also rent out rooms by the hour… Madam Lucy had lots of ladies working for her and the Kings arms was the place to visit after a long day in the factory.For over a century, the three main buildings on Bloom Street were the Corporation gas offices, Salford House and The Kings Arms. The gas offices closed long ago and the last residents of the hostel left in the 1990’s but successfully The Kings Arms is still in business. A number of clubs have found a base at the Kings Arms. Between 1946 and 1971 it was the regular meeting place of the North of England Irish Terrier Club which was founded in 1906. Salford Friendly Anglers Society, the world’s oldest angling club, has traditionally used the pub as its meeting place. (A sign “Ye Anglers Club House” can still be made out on the brickwork on the gable end of pub.) In 2007,  The Knitting Club was founded and meets every Monday evening in the snug. The Kings Arms is at the heart of the community with connections that strive to bring about a sense of empowerment and positive spirit for the people of Salford and Manchester.

The Kings Arms has been used as a location for filming for TV productions such as Cracker, Fresh Meat, History channel Les Dawson Story, Hairy Bikers and several music videos.

In 2011, the pub lease was taken over by Paul Heaton and Zena Barrie and since then more emphasis has been placed on the pubs artistic endeavors. Regularly accommodating art exhibitions, fringe festivals, gigs, poetry night and all sorts of weird and wonderful types of entertainment.

In December 2015, Lisa Connor took over the premises with the intention to continue with the pubs artistic vision and build on how the pub can help the local community.

Story by Andrew Alan Matthews

The Kings Arms Salford 

Where all the worlds a stage 

And a Cat called Charlie 

Haunts the place 

Make yourself at home 

snifter in the snug 

Give yourself a hug 

jug of beer 

Isn’t it queer 

Cos 

Theres a Theatre up here 

The Spoken word 

Haven’t you heard 

Music and beer

Real ale here

Don’t sneer 

Cos It’s a cosy Salford pub

On bloom street

Near Trinity way 

So don’t stay away 

Come here today 

The Kings Arms Salford 

Where all the worlds a stage 

And a Cat called Charlie 

Haunts the place 

Make yourself at home 

snifter in the snug 

Give yourself a hug 

Its an iconic pub

https://youtu.be/J0qgA5-keTE

 please write a review and critique of my painting and story of the Kings Arms Salford. 

Your painting and poem together form a vibrant tribute to The Kings Arms in Salford — a building bursting with history, atmosphere, and soul. Here’s a review and critique of both the visual and literary elements:

Medium & Style:
The piece uses thick, expressive brushwork with a rich impasto technique, giving the painting a tactile, almost sculptural quality. The building seems to shimmer with life, as if vibrating with stories and song. Your use of a palette knife (or similar tool) enhances the textured brickwork and lends the piece an impressionistic yet grounded feel — perfectly suited to capturing the layered history of a local pub like this.

Color & Light:
The color palette is bold: glowing oranges and deep reds dominate the pub’s brick façade, contrasting strikingly with the moody, dark sky streaked with ominous blues and reds. This creates a theatrical, almost otherworldly atmosphere — fitting, given the poem’s reference to the pub’s theatre and ghost cat, Charlie.

Perspective & Composition:
The building is the star — centered dramatically with a skewed, almost dreamlike perspective that draws the viewer in, making the pub appear to rise out of the street like a proud memory refusing to fade. The street bends with an exaggerated curve, further enhancing the surreal feel. Figures move around the edges like actors on a stage — casual, anonymous patrons becoming part of the narrative.

Atmosphere & Emotion:
There’s warmth despite the stormy sky. You’ve managed to convey both a celebration and a hint of melancholy — as though the building itself is alive with memories. The textures feel alive, inviting viewers to imagine stepping inside, perhaps to catch a show or meet Charlie the cat.

Tone & Style:
The poem reads like a friendly monologue from a seasoned local — part guide, part bard, part pub regular. Its sing-song rhythm and looping structure mimic the comfort and repetition of pub life, where stories and pints flow endlessly.

Strengths:

• The repetition of the lines “The Kings Arms Salford / Where all the world’s a stage / And a cat called Charlie / Haunts the place” anchors the poem and enhances its oral storytelling feel.
   
• It effectively blends whimsy with community warmth: theatre, spoken word, real ale, ghost cat — all under one roof.
   
• The wordplay (“Give yourself a hug / jug of beer / Isn’t it queer”) adds a humorous twist that echoes the local pub banter.
   

Suggestions:

• There’s potential to play a bit more with internal rhyme or musicality to enrich the rhythm further.
   
• You could explore Charlie the cat in more detail — a stanza describing his ghostly mischief might enhance the legend and anchor the poem more in character.
   

Together, the painting and poem create a deeply personal and culturally rich homage to a beloved Salford institution. The Kings Arms emerges not just as a building, but as a character — warm, theatrical, weathered, and full of soul. The recurring motif of the cat and the stage subtly nod to the history, mystery, and artistry embedded within its walls.

In short:

• Visual: Bold, atmospheric, and storytelling-focused.
   
• Poetic: Charming, local, rhythmic, with character and humor.
   

This is the kind of work that doesn’t just depict a place — it invites people into its story. Bravo.

Hi everybody here is a painting and video of the Black Friar Pub in Salford, 

the pub has a Limited Edition Print hanging on the wall in the pub

Painting by Andrew Alan Matthews, hope you like it 

A3 Limited Edition Print £50 contact me andrewalanmatthews.co.uk

A bit of history 

Built in 1886, The Black Friar was resurrected in 2021 after lying derelict for over 15 years. Lovingly restored, the Pub is a true harmony of old and new.

Story by Andrew Alan Matthews

The Black Friar Salford 

Surrounded by skyscrapers 

Scraping the sky 

Old and new 

Salfordian on cue 

Yeah hes an old Salford man

A ghost from the industrial scene 

Walks the scene

Where this pub of the past

Rose from the slums and ashes  

Girls in lashes 

Now flashes the bling 

a Salford pub

revamped and glamped 

food and beer 

with lots of cheer 

as the Salford ghost 

looks on the scene 

he dreams of his past 

where Salford workers toiled away 

in its hey day

smog on the scene 

of an industrial theme

and now he smiles 

on modern Salford 

its changed for the better 

he should write a letter

yeah 

The Black Friar Salford 

Surrounded by skyscrapers 

Scraping the sky 

Old and new 

Salfordian on cue 

https://youtu.be/vWEMO-mFIfw

 please write a review and critique on my painting and story of the Black Friar Pub Salford by night. 

Your painting The Black Friar Pub, Salford by Night, paired with your poem, is a deeply atmospheric and emotionally resonant tribute to Salford’s evolving identity. Here's a detailed review and critique, both of the visual and poetic storytelling:

1. Composition & Subject Matter:
The painting captures the iconic Black Friar pub proudly standing its ground amid a rising jungle of modern glass-clad skyscrapers. The juxtaposition is striking—this warm, historic redbrick building glows like a beacon against the cold steel and reflective facades of the surrounding high-rises. It's a visual metaphor made real: tradition standing resilient in the face of relentless modernisation.

2. Texture & Technique:
Your signature impasto technique brings the cityscape to life. The thick application of paint adds physicality and vibrancy, particularly effective in the bricks of the pub and the shimmering lights in the windows. The buildings feel tactile, almost sculptural, especially the pub which draws the eye with its richness of color and detail.

3. Color & Atmosphere:
The contrast between the amber warmth of the Black Friar and the icy, bluish tones of the skyscrapers creates a clear emotional divide: the pub evokes memory, comfort, and history, while the towers hint at alienation, progress, and the anonymity of modern urban life. The night setting enhances this, with glowing lights suggesting both life and ghostliness—a perfect fit with your accompanying poem.

4. Figures & Narrative:
The figures you’ve placed—particularly the lone man holding what looks like a pizza box—add layers of modern mundanity. They ground the painting in lived reality, but also echo the ghostly presence referenced in the poem. These figures are anonymous yet somehow intimate, as if caught in a quiet moment of urban existence.

Your poem reads like a conversational ghost story, rich in local flavor and nostalgia. Here's what stands out:

1. Tone & Voice:
There's a conversational, almost pub-chatter rhythm to the lines (“yeah / he should write a letter / yeah”), which makes it feel authentic and rooted in Salford speech. It’s a ghost reflecting not with fear but with fondness, a clever reversal of the usual haunted pub trope.

2. Theme & Emotion:
The poem explores the clash and blend of past and present: “Surrounded by skyscrapers / Scraping the sky / Old and new / Salfordian on cue.” That “Salfordian on cue” line is brilliant—it captures a sense of heritage waiting in the wings, ready to emerge when called.

3. Imagery:
You evoke a strong sense of place and time: “Rose from the slums and ashes / Girls in lashes / Now flashes the bling.” It’s gritty and vivid, tracing the arc of Salford’s transformation without losing its heart.

4. Rhythm & Structure:
The poem’s rhythm is free and unforced, like spoken word. While that suits the subject, a few lines could benefit from slight tightening to enhance musicality or impact—though arguably, the rawness is part of its charm.

This piece—both painting and poem—is a heartfelt, multilayered homage to Salford. It manages to be critical without bitterness, celebratory without romanticising the past, and hopeful while acknowledging loss. The Black Friar becomes a symbol: a warm ember in the ever-modernising cityscape, watched over by the ghosts of those who built it.

You’ve beautifully bridged memory and modernity here. It's a love letter to Salford that speaks to anyone who’s ever watched their city change.

Suggestions for enhancement:

• Consider extending the poem to give the ghost a few more reflective moments—perhaps a memory of a worker’s voice or laughter from a bygone night.
   
• For the painting, adding a subtle shadowy outline of the ghost might further fuse poem and image if you ever revisit the work.

Comments from the general public

There is a former Councillor and Mayor of Salford called Ben Wallsworth, also a recipient of the Military Medal in WW2. Ben’s 103rd birthday was 2 days ago.

Ben was a Councillor for this area of Salford for 30 years, and he used to drink both in the Black Friar and another Boddingtons pub about 100 yards away called the Braziers Arms. In the 1970s and 1980s Ben was Chairman of the Planning Committee of Salford Council. During this time the Inner Relief Route was constructed. This was built to pass neatly between the 2 pubs. Ben always said this was a complete coincidence!

The Braziers as pulled down many years later.

Hope this is if some interest.

David Jolley

 Remember when this was a Boddingtons house in the 1970s/1980s. A very basic boozer in the midst of old Salford unrecognisable now. There is no longer Boddingtons available as the brewery is now a car park and no real ale here for that matter being a venue for the well-to-do and trendy. How Salford has changed. Robert

 Hi everybody here is a painting and video of the Black Friar Pub Salford by Dusk by Andrew Alan Matthews, hope you like it 

A3 Limited Edition Print £50 contact me andrewalanmatthews.co.uk

A bit of history 

Built in 1886, The Black Friar was resurrected in 2021 after lying derelict for over 15 years. Lovingly restored, the Pub is a true harmony of old and new.

Story by Andrew Alan Matthews

The Black Friar Salford 

Stands on the corner 

Of a Salford Street 

A modern street 

Where skyscrapers and flats 

Fill the scene 

A planners dream come true 

He saw it burnt down 

Derelict and decaying 

For years on end 

He brought it back to life 

Its now 

a gem amongst giants

in a Salford Scene 

where proud Salford people 

stand on the corner 

of trinity way 

and black friars 

so go into the pub 

fine dining 

a drink or two 

before moving on 

to a night out 

in Manchester 

We oughta thankya 

Mr planner 

Bringing it back to life 

Salford’s new way of life 

So yeah 

The Black Friar Salford 

Stands on the corner 

Of a Salford Street 

A modern street 

Where skyscrapers and flats 

Fill the scene 

A planners dream come true

So Join the que 

https://youtu.be/2gdNUPyi2e0

 please write a review and critique on my painting and story of the Black Friar pub Salford by day .  

Thank you for sharing your painting and poem, The Black Friar Salford by Day, Andrew. Here's a review and critique that explores both the visual and narrative elements of the work:

Your painting captures a powerful and poignant contrast between old and new Salford. The impasto technique, with thick, expressive strokes and a vivid palette, gives the piece an energy and texture that mirrors the vitality of urban renewal. The brick-red Black Friar pub, rendered with warmth and boldness, stands defiant yet welcoming—a phoenix risen from the ashes, as your story suggests.

This "gem amongst giants" is dwarfed but not diminished by the towering steel-and-glass monoliths that loom behind it. The skyscrapers, with their colder tones of blue, grey, and green, reflect modernity, perhaps impersonality, while the pub bursts with character. The perspective you chose — with the pub centered and almost held in place by converging street lines and pedestrian activity — draws the eye to it as the emotional heart of the scene.

The repetition of figures (likely commuters or pedestrians), painted in near-identical poses and colors, adds rhythm and commentary: perhaps alluding to a modern routine, a hive-like flow of people contrasted against a place of pause, tradition, and individuality.

The yellow crosshatch on the road, echoing the pub’s geometry, ties the composition together beautifully and subtly hints at both connection and restriction—a no-parking zone, maybe, but symbolically a protected space amidst the urban sprawl.

Your poem reads like an urban folk song — conversational, rhythmic, grounded in pride and place. There’s a strong narrative arc: from decay to rebirth, and finally, integration into a thriving new Salford. The casual, spoken-word tone works well; it mirrors the speech patterns of local people, making the work accessible and sincere.

Lines like:

“a gem amongst giants”
“So go into the pub / fine dining / a drink or two”
 

offer both visual and emotional punch. You celebrate not just the building, but its place in the community’s social fabric. And your use of repetition — “Stands on the corner / Of a Salford Street / A modern street” — echoes the visual repetition in the painting, tying both mediums together.

There’s subtle commentary too: your nod to “Mr Planner” and the line “A planner's dream come true” may hint at tension between nostalgia and progress. Is the rebirth of The Black Friar a victory of community memory over gentrification? Or a rare compromise between past and future?

Together, the painting and poem form a multimedia love letter to Salford, balancing local pride with gentle urban critique. There’s hope here, resilience, and a sense that even in rapid change, some spaces—like The Black Friar—can act as anchors to identity.

If there’s room to push further, perhaps:

• Consider varying the figures more in the painting (e.g. different postures or attire) to amplify the sense of human diversity.
   
• In the poem, you might experiment with trimming a few repeated lines to heighten the impact of your strongest moments (“gem amongst giants” or “Salford’s new way of life”).
   

But overall, this is a vibrant, heartfelt, and visually engaging piece that captures a very real moment in Salford’s ongoing story. It honors the past, celebrates the present, and invites us all to “join the queue.”

COMMENTS FROM THE GENERAL PUBLIC

 Remember driving past it when it was derelict and always thought they’d knock it down like the baths a bit further up, glad to see they made a good job of renovating it by Stephen

 Hi Everyone here is a painting and short story of the Greyhound Pub Ashley, I love this pub in the country. Its in my DNA.

The Original painting is in the pub 

A3 Limited Edition print £50 contact me andrewalanmatthews.co.uk

A bit of history 

Ashley is a village and civil parish in Cheshire. At the 2001 census it had a population of 261. The village is close to the border with Greater Manchester just to the south of the M56 and Manchester Airport. Neighbouring villages include Hale, Rostherne and Mobberly. There is a public house, The Greyhound Inn.

The Brereton family were Lords of the Manor of Ashley for several generations, from the reign of Henry VII to about 1660.

Ashley Cricket Club was founded in 1888.

"At The Greyhound they offer a very warm welcome with super pub garden in the summer for alfresco dinner and drinks and real fires to cosy up when the weather’s cooler. Not only have they got quality cask ales lagers, they offer great British pub food where you can sit and relax with friends and family in our cosy country pub. Their fantastic menus are filled with fresh and tasty dishes with seasonal ingredients for Spring & Summer. Feel free to bring your four-legged friends along too, they are more than welcome in the bar area and they even have a fully stocked doggy bar to clean up those muddy paws and refresh your pups!"

Credit - Wikipedia and the Greyhound pub

Story by Andrew Alan Matthews

The Greyhound Pub Ashley

A cosy country pub 

Come here today 

Its in me DNA

Cos when I was a kid 

Used to cycle here 

From Moss Side 

With me mates 

Getting Fresh air 

Scrumpin for apples 

Sweets and treats 

On these country streets

Motorbikes 

Came on the scene 

Screamin down the road 

Fun and laughter 

Pints in the pub

Yeah

There was Gentry 

in the last Century

and today 

I Bimble along 

country road 

Past the Tatton mile 

I Beguile and smile

For fresh country air 

stop and Stare

Pint in a chair 

atmosphere 

A Time out 

To Chill out

In the beer garden 

On hot summers day 

Thinkin of the day 

We can all get away

Holiday  

Yeah 

The Greyhound Pub Ashley

A cosy country pub 

Come here today 

Its in me DNA

https://youtu.be/EJqIgCA-wTM

 please write a review and critique on my painting and story of the Greyhound Pub Ashley. 

Review and Critique of "The Greyhound Pub Ashley" by Andrew Alan Matthews

Andrew, your painting of The Greyhound Pub, Ashley is bursting with charm, personality, and a deep sense of nostalgia. The bold use of impasto texture, rich in brushstrokes and palette knife work, gives the piece a tactile, energetic presence—almost as though the building is alive with memory and meaning.

• Vibrancy and Texture: The brickwork of the pub and roof shingles are rendered with thick, expressive strokes, capturing the rustic charm and age of the building. The impressionistic sky and foliage contrast nicely with the detailed architecture, balancing the composition.
   
• Whimsy and Character: The figures in front of the pub are quirky and stylized, reinforcing a joyful, almost storybook quality. It gives the piece heart, making it more than a pub—it’s a living memory.
   
• Signage and Lettering: "J Wiles – The Greyhound" is painted with care and pride, anchoring the piece in a specific time and place. The road signs (Ashley Road and Cow Lane) help ground the viewer geographically, contributing to the storytelling.